Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill

Lord Winston Excerpts

Friday 21st November 2025 Lords Chamber

[Baroness Hollins (CB)]

I thank the noble Baroness. I thought about that, and it could indeed be brought back in a different way later in the debate, but I feel that the prevention of coercion is really important, so thinking about it at this stage is really helpful.

[Lord Winston (Lab)]

My Lords, I want to ask this question of the noble Baroness, Lady Hollins, but it applies also to the noble Baroness, Lady Berridge: she mentioned various things that are cited as causing pressure, but does she not agree that being in palliative care also causes pressure?

[Baroness Hollins (CB)]

There is no suggestion in anything that I have said of imposing palliative care—none at all. I have listened to the debate, and I was not going to speak personally but I will now, since the noble Lord has challenged me on that. My husband was dying with motor neurone disease last year. He felt under immense pressure from this debate in the House of Commons, the other place. He found it very difficult. It made him ask questions, such as, “Am I still entitled to palliative care? Am I really entitled at a time when the NHS is so short of staff and short of time?” He worried about that, and I had to offer him a lot of reassurance so that he could make his own decision. He was not ready to die. The idea that offering palliative care applies pressure is really not to understand the whole nature of the dying process and the way in which, as we come to realise that our life is coming to an end, we need time to understand, reflect, heal and make sense. The pressure not to be a burden is huge, and the pressure of not having access to services that are in short supply is much worse.

[Lord Winston (Lab)]

I do not wish to extend this conversation but, given what the noble Baroness has said, can she explain why in Australia—I am sorry, in New Zealand—where there is very good palliative care, three-quarters of the people requesting assisted dying, something like 2,000 patients, had been in palliative care at the time of the request?