Health and Social Care Bill

Lord Stoddart of Swindon Excerpts

Monday 28th November 2011 Lords Chamber

[Baroness Finlay of Llandaff]

My Lords, I would be grateful if the Minister could let us know whether the department considered the BMA resolution in council at the end of last week to now oppose the Bill and campaign against it, when the BMA was coming to its decision to appeal against the release of the information. If not, will it be considered in the next steps the Government take, given that it signals a major loss of confidence in the Bill by the BMA?

[Lord Stoddart of Swindon]

How long is it likely to take for the appeal and the decision? If the decision disallows the appeal, will the Government accept that?

[Lord Butler of Brockwell]

My Lords, the problem is not what may be contained in a particular risk register, as the Minister has said, but the precedent that it sets for all other risk registers. There may be nothing in this register that is particularly sensational or has not been released. However, once this case is conceded it will nullify the effect of all risk registers across government. If people think these risk registers are valuable it must be the case, as the Minister has said, that people look at the worst risks and do so frankly, and if they make them anodyne then the purpose of the registers is entirely lost.