Debates between Lisa Smart and Katie Lam during the 2024 Parliament

Wed 2nd Sep 2026

Representation of the People Bill

Debate between Lisa Smart and Katie Lam
Katie Lam Portrait Katie Lam
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

When I have finished this point, I will give way. It should terrify all of us that election material in our country is being produced in a foreign language and designed to drum up support among a particular religious community. Not only does this contribute to a culture of group-based grievance politics, but it makes it impossible for the vast majority of the British public to scrutinise what candidates are saying.

Lisa Smart Portrait Lisa Smart (Hazel Grove) (LD)
- Hansard - -

I wonder whether the shadow Secretary of State sees a certain irony in attempting to legislate for linguistic purity in a language that, for over a millennium, has borrowed vocabulary ad hoc from other languages, such as Italian, Latin and French, and in a Bill that talks about elections, referendums, vetoes and manifestos. There is perhaps more than a little hint of irony in what she is proposing.

Katie Lam Portrait Katie Lam
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The fact that English takes words from other languages does not mean that an English voter, or indeed any British voter, would be able to read election material in Latin. The point is that our voters must be able to understand the election literature that is being produced, and if it is not produced in a language of the British Isles, they cannot.