Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
Visitor Levy (England) Bill Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateJulian Smith
Main Page: Julian Smith (Conservative - Skipton and Ripon)Department Debates - View all Julian Smith's debates with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
(2 days, 4 hours ago)
Commons ChamberI refer the House to my entry in the Register of Members’ Financial Interests.
I am really upset. I really like the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government and it is deeply upsetting to speak so negatively about her Bill. North Yorkshire hospitality, like so many areas of the UK hospitality sector, is only just recovering from covid. It has been on its knees and it is now being battered by high energy costs, high wage costs, high rates costs, inflation pressure impacting spending, and a welter of employment legislation that is about to come down the track. Not all of that is the Government’s fault. Some of those factors are not within the Government’s control, but many are.
It is challenging at the moment for hoteliers or campsite owners anywhere in the UK, but in North Yorkshire and in particular in my constituency which is very rural, those challenges are especially acute. It is more difficult, because venues are less straightforward to get to, impacting visitor footfall, staffing and supply chain costs. Let us take a hotel or a campsite deep in the heart of the Yorkshire Dales. Getting staff and the cost of getting staff is a major challenge. Some hotels have to offer accommodation or bus services. Transport, food and drink supply costs are higher in remote locations. Energy supply, already tough for all providers of accommodation, is more expensive off-grid. Broadband and other services, too, are more expensive. Other considerations need to be added to the cost of running a rural hotel. It might be further away than is reasonable from a hospital, so more healthcare needs to be provided onsite. Planning a hotel expansion in beautiful areas such as North Yorkshire is more difficult, because it takes longer to go through the planning process.
The UK hospitality sector is worried about the Government’s plans, but those in North Yorkshire hospitality are really frightened by the additional layer of tax and bureaucracy at a time when they and their businesses are only just surviving. The Tourism Alliance has talked about the seasonal aspect for rural and coastal destinations that compete on price and are more exposed. As we have heard, rural destinations depend much more on domestic and price-sensitive visitors. Communicating the fragility of the current situation in rural hospitality is key, because almost all the hospitality businesses I work with are not making a profit. They are losing money, obviously, but one more hammer blow could tip them over, and that means less revenue and fewer jobs.
I am listening to the right hon. Gentleman’s speech and I agree that the new plan needs to be done in consultation with businesses. Does he at least acknowledge that the visitor levy could be used to supply transport, for instance? He was talking about getting people to and from home and work.
I thank the hon. Lady for that intervention, but the case I am making is that we need lower taxes and less taxation to encourage more visitors, and for the cost of running a business to be less of a stress.
More than 6,000 people in my constituency of Skipton and Ripon are employed in accommodation and food services. Often, as we heard earlier, these are jobs for the very young people we are trying to get back into employment. Not just the direct jobs are affected. Local food producers, taxi drivers, electricians, technicians and others who supply the businesses, and the pubs, restaurants, tourist sites and venues all need the footfall. Jobseekers and local suppliers are already worrying about the consultation on shooting. Shoots in constituencies such as mine provide many, many dinners and events at this time of year, so many venues are already worried.
We have heard from the Secretary of State about the Mayor of York and North Yorkshire, who has already said that he is going to whack a 5% tax on—it could be more—which means that we will be competing against Lancashire, Northumberland and other attractive counties that may not apply a tax at all. We have also heard about the huge further administrative costs for those businesses, which are really struggling. We want them to invest in their businesses, not in HMRC services.
Given the context of the challenges facing the sector, the only responsible thing is to put the Bill on hold. Yes, there are lots of issues around the consultation—rural protections, caps, limits to the duration of the levy and reviews of the policy—but I want the Secretary of State to come to North Yorkshire. I will pay for a night in a hotel, and then she can see how hard those people are working, and she can pause the Bill and bring it back when she is leader of the Labour party in a few Parliaments’ time.