Hospital Services (South Manchester)

Jeff Smith Excerpts

Tuesday 8th September 2015 Westminster Hall

[Jeff Smith (Manchester, Withington) (Lab)]

Thank you, Mr Hollobone, for the opportunity to take part in today’s debate. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship for the first time. I echo other hon. Members’ congratulations to my hon. Friend the Member for Wythenshawe and Sale East (Mike Kane) on securing the debate.

I will be brief because I do not want to repeat other hon. Members’ comments about Healthier Together, but I agree with a number of concerns raised about the process. The consultation was less than ideal and I think we all agree that the model needs review to ensure that we deliver the highest quality services for patients. I also agree that there was a strong case for awarding Wythenshawe the fourth specialist status. The high quality of the services at that hospital has already been outlined and the transport connectivity, especially given the new developments of the Metrolink line and the relief road, makes it the best option.

Like other Members here, I was disappointed by the decision not to award the fourth specialist status to Wythenshawe. What is key now is for the assurances that we have been given in relation to the existing specialisms to be robust, and for those services to be protected. I visited Wythenshawe hospital over the summer and saw for myself some of the absolutely excellent, world-leading specialist heart and vascular care provided there. What I took away from that visit more than anything was how much some of that excellent specialist provision relied on high-quality general surgery support. I agree that it is vital that we do not lose those connections and that expertise.

Having expressed disappointment about the process and the outcome of the consultation and decision making, we should not be blind to the opportunities that we now have in healthcare in Greater Manchester, particularly south Manchester. Co-operation, not competition, needs to be the future for our NHS. That is what lies behind the principles of Healthier Together, which we agree with, and the plans for devolution of health funding and organisation to Greater Manchester.

[Angela Rayner]

I congratulate the hon. Member for Altrincham and Sale West (Mr Brady) and my hon. Friends the Members for Wythenshawe and Sale East (Mike Kane) and for Stretford and Urmston (Kate Green) on making a compelling case, which I hope the Minister listens to.

Does my hon. Friend the Member for Manchester, Withington (Jeff Smith) agree that when we are looking at devolution and the reconfiguration of health across Greater Manchester, the evidence shows overwhelmingly that public opinion will be undermined if we rush ahead with a proposal that is clearly not good for the people of Greater Manchester? People have genuine concerns that we will not achieve the fantastic things that we could by looking at reconfiguration of health. We must consider pausing the situation and listen to the general population of Greater Manchester, giving them a voice in this process which they feel they have not had so far.

[Jeff Smith]

My hon. Friend makes an excellent point. Clearly, Wythenshawe was the public choice for a specialist hospital.

On working together, which I was just talking about, there is clearly a growing and improved relationship between Wythenshawe and the Manchester Royal Infirmary. Some people see that as a concern, but I think that it is very much to be welcomed and we need to see it as an opportunity.

In south Manchester, we have the opportunity to be an exemplar of partnership working. We have two fine hospitals in Wythenshawe and the MRI, which are on either side of my constituency. My constituency also houses the excellent—and, I believe, underused—facilities at Withington community hospital, which was established under the last Labour Government. I look forward to an expanded role for Withington community hospital in health provision in south Manchester, supporting the two major hospitals and providing joined-up services for all our communities.

We have an opportunity to use Withington community hospital to integrate community services, primary care, secondary care and mental health support, with health services and social care services working together for the benefit of all the community in Manchester Withington and the whole of south Manchester. I urge everyone involved to make the most of that opportunity to expand and improve services at Withington community hospital.

I agree with many comments that hon. Members have made about the Healthier Together process, but I welcome the opportunity to use all those hospital resources together—to use Withington as a thriving community hospital to improve health outcomes for people in south Manchester.

[Mr Philip Hollobone (in the Chair)]

Before I call the Front Benchers, I should say that we are going to have the pleasure of hearing Mike Kane sum up the debate for three minutes at the end. I would be grateful if the Front Benchers would be kind enough to leave him enough time to do that and if he would be kind enough to leave me 30 seconds at the very end to put the motion to the Chamber.