Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
Visitor Levy (England) Bill Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateJames Wild
Main Page: James Wild (Conservative - North West Norfolk)Department Debates - View all James Wild's debates with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
(2 days ago)
Commons ChamberIt is a pleasure to follow my hon. Friend the Member for Bridgwater (Sir Ashley Fox) and to respond to the debate on behalf of His Majesty’s Opposition. The hon. Member for South Shields (Emma Lewell) began the debate from the Back Benches with a stark warning about the impact that such a tax could have when imposed on an area and the damage it could do to a sector. In contrast, the hon. Member for Crawley (Peter Lamb) said that the concerns being raised were a storm in a tea cup.
That complacency does not reflect the threat to what the Chair of the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee, my hon. Friend the Member for Gosport (Dame Caroline Dinenage), pointed out is a key part of our GDP and economy. As my right hon. Friend the Member for Skipton and Ripon (Sir Julian Smith) said, businesses in the sector are only just surviving. As my right hon. Friend the Member for Witham (Priti Patel) put it, we should be encouraging more visitors to create more opportunities in the sector. As an MP for a coastal area who grew up on the North Norfolk coast, I enjoyed the speech from my hon. Friend the Member for Bognor Regis and Littlehampton (Alison Griffiths) about seaside holidays.
My hon. Friend the Member for North Dorset (Simon Hoare) posed the key question: what is the problem that this tax seeks to address? This Labour Government, like all Labour Governments, like to tax. In their first two Budgets, they increased taxes by £66 billion, hitting businesses, farmers, savers, investors, pensioners and working people. Our hospitality and leisure sectors have been hammered by the jobs tax and by the significant increase in business rates imposed by the Government, with over 100,000 job losses since the election. What is the response of a Prime Minister who said he wants to give households struggling with the cost of living some “breathing space”? This new holiday tax—a tax on family breaks, a tax that hits businesses, a tax that will damage our economy, and a tax that the Conservatives will vote against this evening.
The visitor economy is worth about £147 billion a year, supporting 3 million jobs. Every year, as we have heard, there are 43 million international visits to the UK, and this new tax has been sold by the Government as a way to raise money from those international visitors. Ministers claim that it will simply bring us in line with other European countries, but they ignore that we have higher VAT rates and higher business rates on hospitality than many other countries.
Let us not be hoodwinked into believing that this is primarily a tax on foreign visitors. It has been estimated that over 60% of the revenue will be paid by British people taking trips, so—despite what the Government might claim—this is a tax on hard-working British families. Weekends away, a family holiday or a few nights by the seaside will all cost more. This is a tax on staycations. According to the Housing Secretary, who I am pleased to see in her place,
“most people won’t even notice a tiny little bit extra”.
Frankly, that shows how out of touch she is, when this could see over £100 added to a family’s bill for a typical week-long break, making many trips unaffordable for many of my constituents, and perhaps for hers and for others across the country.
Every pound that is taken in tax is a pound not spent in the local economy. As UKHospitality, the Country Land and Business Association and others have said, those meals will not be had in the pub, and those visits to the local attraction and those taxi rides with local businesses will not happen. This Government do not seem to understand that if you tax something, you get less of it.
Can my hon. Friend confirm, for those who wish to dismiss the significance of this tax, that, like me, he has received emails from constituents on this? I have received one that says: “My husband and I both already work, but we struggle to afford family holidays. Another tax will price me and all working families out of British holidays.”
I have indeed had similar representations, and I would be amazed if hon. Members on the Government Benches have not had similar ones. Some of them have spoken up on behalf of those constituents, but others have chosen to put their head in the sand and pretend that this is not happening.
Oxford Economics has warned that a 5% levy could cost 33,000 jobs and cut visitor spending by £1.7 billion. Ministers can challenge those figures if they like, but the Government have not published an impact assessment. Why such a lack of candour about the impact on jobs and the economy, I wonder. Did they listen to the representations to their own consultation, which concluded that
“a visitor levy could reduce holiday affordability, deter overnight stays or encourage UK travellers to choose destinations abroad”?
When all tourism areas are trying to extend day trips and encourage more overnight stays and visitors all year round, that is a damning verdict on Labour’s holiday tax.
I think I will return to the point that has been made by the shadow Secretary of State and other hon. Members: we need to look at the other tax rates within those countries, including the higher VAT and business rates.
Importantly, this tax is not just going to hit people going on holiday. Research for Airbnb has found that British patients and families spend over 600,000 nights a year away from home in private accommodation for medical reasons. How can the Government justify this tax being faced by people travelling for medical treatment or to care for their sick child or family member?
Businesses will also face higher costs, through the 5 million business trips a year. Why are Labour Mayors so keen to hit the electricians, the plumbers, the fit-out engineers and the sales reps who typically stay overnight mid-week in budget accommodation? Far from cutting the cost of business, the Chancellor is loading on more costs, just like his predecessor did. He is loading more costs on to hard-working families, just like his predecessor did—and the people working in the hospitality and tourism sector, particularly those young people wanting that first opportunity in rural and coastal areas, will suffer the most.
A repeated theme of the debate has been which types of accommodation will be covered. As it stands, the Bill includes all short-term visitor overnight accommodation: hotels, B&Bs, campsites, campervan pitches and self-catering cottages. It could even include scout camps, despite the Scout Association pointing out these are
“being run for charitable purposes by volunteers, on minimal budgets”.
Even tents at music festivals are covered. So what is actually excluded from the legislation? The Government have selected three national exemptions, one of which is Traveller sites. There is a power to exempt more categories, but that is discretionary, so scout camps and other sites are liable by default. The Secretary of State did not have a view on scout camps, but we do and other Labour Members have a view. Scout camps should be exempt, and we will be bringing forward amendments to that effect. This should not be left to the whims of mayors. This House should set the framework.
Extraordinarily, or perhaps not, the Government want this to be an uncapped power to charge an unlimited amount. Although Labour mayors, who cannot wait to introduce this tax, say that they will limit it to 5%, there is nothing in the Bill to prevent higher rates. The Government are even adding VAT to the levy, pushing it up even further. It will apply to 28 days of a stay, not five days, as in Scotland. Frankly, it does not take much imagination to see those Labour mayors breaking promises on tax, just like their Front Benchers did after the election. The Government have said that whether to have a cap is a finely balanced issue. No, it is not. It is very straightforward: there should be a cap to protect the public. If the Bill passes, we will seek to amend it to limit the tax to 5%.
We have a Labour Mayor of the West Midlands. Does my hon. Friend agree that the Bill gives local people in my constituency no reassurance whatsoever that the levy will be 5%, let alone that it will actually benefit the residents of my constituency and the Walsall borough? This is not devolution at all.
In many ways, this is taxation without representation or any benefit for my right hon. Friend’s constituents. A number of Members made that point. The Housing Secretary has not been here for much of the debate; otherwise, she would have heard those points. She can read them in Hansard tomorrow if she wishes.
What will these uncapped tax rises be used for? This is called a visitor levy—that is the name of the Bill—but nothing in the legislation states that the proceeds must be reinvested in supporting the visitor economy. The Bill does not mention tourism at all, unlike the equivalent Scottish legislation, which states that money must benefit the objectives of the scheme and the tourism economy. If a new tax is to benefit tourism, it must be ringfenced in the legislation for that purpose. The Minister will have heard many calls for that.
We all know that the Government are itching to impose these new tax-raising powers. In Scotland, there must be an 18-month gap between a decision to impose the levy and its taking effect. The Government proposed a 12-month gap for businesses in their consultation, and three quarters of people agreed with them that that was a good idea. What did they do? They ditched that idea. Why might they have done that? Removing that gap and protection shows a motivation simply to get these tax-raising powers in place as rapidly as possible.
Businesses will have to collect this tax, but, again, there is no specific provision in the legislation to cover the costs of their collecting those taxes, unlike the approach taken in Scotland. That burden will fall on the smallest businesses and owner-operators. We know that they are working people—it is the Chief Secretary to the Treasury who does not consider them to be. The strategic authorities will take on local tax administration, and get HMRC-style information, inspection powers, and the ability to charge interest and penalties. Small wonder that businesses are concerned there will be a potential proliferation of systems and registers, rather than a simple collection system.
This Government have already hammered our tourism and leisure sectors. Now they are coming back for more—with attacks not just on holidays, but on people working away to provide for their families, people staying to support friends and family in hospital, and even on scout camps. That will mean higher prices for families, fewer opportunities for young people to get jobs and lower growth in the economy.
Rather than hiking taxes, Conservatives are backing hospitality and the visitor economy with our plans to cut business rates for 250,000 businesses in the sector, to encourage more international visitors by reintroducing VAT-free shopping, and to make it easier and cheaper to hire people. As the hospitality sector has said, the public want their holidays kept “relaxing, not taxing”. That is our approach, and we reject the calls for this new tax.