(1 day, 9 hours ago)
Commons ChamberIt is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Surrey Heath (Dr Pinkerton). This debate has been mainly in two parts. If I may use the phrase, there is a weary familiarity to the conversation taking place on the Conservative Benches about what Brexit meant. I have reflected on this matter over a long time, and the Conservatives remind me of diners who go into a restaurant and order a Brexit, having no idea what it will be. When the dish arrives, they say, “This isn’t what I ordered.” Why is that? Because there is a clear dissonance between the promises that were made and the reality. Their only way to deal with that is to say, “Waiter, waiter! This isn’t what I ordered.” That is what they do, rather than opening up to the fact that the promises that were made have not come to pass.
Let me touch on Northern Ireland, which was mentioned earlier. The fact that Northern Ireland has the arrangements that it does was completely predictable, because we ended up with the United Kingdom, which was no longer in the European Union, having one set of rules; Ireland, which was still in the EU, and the rest of the EU having the European set of rules; and an open border between the two entities. Here is the question: how were we going to manage trade across an open border? It was plain-as-a-pikestaff obvious that the only way we could do that, given that the border was open, was by ensuring that goods arriving in Northern Ireland complied with the rules of the EU. Out of that came the Windsor framework.
Once again, I pay tribute to the last Government for what they negotiated in the Windsor framework, which made things just about workable. About the only thing that all parties in Northern Ireland agreed on during my time as Secretary of State for Northern Ireland was their welcome for the SPS agreement, which my hon. Friend the Minister spoke about. That was precisely because it will make the movement of goods so much easier.
The other debate that we have been having this afternoon is of a very different character, and it is about the way in which the world has changed in the last 10 years. I urge the House to lift up its eyes collectively and look around us at the world in which we live. The public’s view of Brexit has changed quite significantly, in so far as one can tell from the polling that has been done, because the public can see that it has been bad for our economy; the evidence of that is growing all the time. That is not very surprising. If you make trade with your biggest, nearest and most important trading partners more difficult, and make it involve more paperwork and more bureaucracy, do not be surprised if it damages your economy. However, it is also because other things have changed, and we are living in new circumstances.
Who would have thought, decades after the fall of the Berlin wall, which was referenced, that Russia would invade Ukraine? Look at the threats we face, including people’s ability to turn up the temperature of freezers remotely and ruin all the food—something that no one appears able to prevent; other types of cyber-attack; the threat to communications; the vulnerability of our cables; hybrid conflict; and the fact that the United States of America, under the current President, has revelled in removing itself from international agreements, and has called into question the long-standing US commitment to the security of Europe.
We have seen populism spreading, and I very much regret that the official Opposition in this House are now advocating for our leaving the European convention on human rights. Winston Churchill would not recognise the Conservative party of today, because he supported that, and it is very striking that the former Leader of the Opposition William Hague gave an interview in which he said, “I couldn’t be a candidate for the Conservatives at the next election, because I do not agree with leaving the European convention on human rights.” By the way, doing so would have serious implications for the Good Friday agreement.
We see the climate continuing to change, and we talk a lot about migration. When it comes to our relations with the European Union, migration is clearly an issue. The great irony is that the last Government, having left the EU while arguing, “This is the way to take back control”, completely lost control of migration from the rest of the world, which they had control over from the very start. That had nothing to do with the European Union. We see populism spreading, and we have a world of economic powerhouses—China, the United States, Russia, and of course Europe.
If anyone wants proof that our interests lie in a strong and close relationship with Europe, they should consider this question: when Russia invaded Ukraine, what happened in Europe? The countries of Europe rushed to meet—to ask, “What the hell are we going to do about this?”. It did not matter whether those countries were in the European Union or not, because the countries of Europe, including the United Kingdom, instinctively realised that this was a new threat, and that we would need to work together to deal with it. Co-operating with our neighbouring countries and like-minded countries is not a betrayal, and I could not agree more with what the Minister had to say about that.
The right hon. Gentleman is speaking with his customary passion. His reference to the invasion of Ukraine is not relevant, for one good reason, which is that the UK was first to come out in support of Ukraine. Most importantly, though, the NATO framework under which all those countries gathered is about collective defence. The EU is not about collective defence—it is about wholly different issues. I would be grateful if the right hon. Gentleman recognised that.
Obviously, I agree with the right hon. Gentleman about the role and importance of NATO, but we have seen a big change in the attitudes of EU member states to defence and defence spending, which is also reflected here in the United Kingdom. It is possible to argue both that NATO is the bedrock of our defence—it has been since it was created—and that having a closer relationship with the European Union is also important to our defence, including when it comes to purchasing military equipment. That is why progress on the Made in Europe question will be so important for us.
I was making the point that working with other countries is not a betrayal, because it is the best way of protecting and advancing the interests of the people who send us to Parliament to represent them. Of course, one of the great political challenges is where we strike the balance between the supranational and the local or devolved. In part, the Brexit referendum had that question at its heart, because people had it put to them, “Would you like to have some control?”. To be frank, if many of my constituents had been asked, “Do you feel you have any control over what is happening in the world out there?”, they would have said, “I don’t have any control at all over what is happening.” However, this is about striking a balance in a more complex world. Co-operating on trade will undoubtedly help our economy; helping our economy will give us growth; and growth is what we need to generate revenues to pay for many of the things that we would all like Governments to do. The agreement that the Government hope to conclude on Friday—and I wish them every success in their endeavours—is a really important first step towards what I hope will be the destination of putting us back in the heart of Europe.
(11 months ago)
Commons ChamberUrgent Questions are proposed each morning by backbench MPs, and up to two may be selected each day by the Speaker. Chosen Urgent Questions are announced 30 minutes before Parliament sits each day.
Each Urgent Question requires a Government Minister to give a response on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
I agree with that statement completely, which is why I must confess my disappointment that the Opposition are still clinging to the notion of immunity, including immunity for terrorists. The Veterans Commissioners are quite right; they want fairness, and that is what the Government are determined to deliver.
I simply say to the Secretary of State that it does seem like ridiculous haste when the Bill is going through the House right now. Surely to do this when he knows for a fact that there is already an appeal going on does, as has already been said, become abusive of the real purpose of a remedial order. I suggest to him that all the stuff about people being let off and the whole point about immunity is not the issue. The issue today is whether the Government are misusing their powers to rush something through that they could have dealt with through the passage of the Bill.
I will make two points to the right hon. Gentleman, who served with such distinction in Northern Ireland. First, as we have just heard, immunity was never commenced. It was declared incompatible, and it was struck down under article 2. Secondly, I reject again the suggestion that the Government are somehow abusing the process. If that was an argument, one might have expected the Joint Committee on Human Rights to have agreed with it, but it did not. The Committee heard all the points that have been put and concluded that in these particular circumstances it was right to proceed, and that is why it recommends that the House should support the remedial order.
(1 year ago)
Commons ChamberI gently say to the hon. Gentleman that I do not accept the characterisation he used at the end of his question. This is not a politically correct process; this is about trying to find a way forward for those families. The honest answer to the fair point that he raises is that each family deals with the loss of their loved one in their own way. Some do not come forward. They live with their grief silently, alone. Others have campaigned. If it had not been for the campaigning of the Bloody Sunday families, there would not have been a Saville inquiry and we would not have got to the point where the former Prime Minister stood at this Dispatch Box to apologise for the killing of their loved ones.
Having said that, in the vast majority of cases, no one is likely to be held to account through a judicial process, and that is why one of the focuses of the new commission will be on fact-finding and the new body for information retrieval, using all the means at our disposal to try to provide answers to those families. It will then be for them to decide how they come to terms with what happened. We owe it to them to leave no stone unturned and to put a better system in place.
As someone who served in Northern Ireland, I just remind the House that this was the most peculiar operation that we could ever expect soldiers to do—patrolling streets in this United Kingdom, defending people against terrorists here in the UK, against a very strict rules of engagement booklet. They had to make complex decisions in a split second. Some of them were 18 years old, on the streets, petrified. In that context, I simply say to the right hon. Gentleman that he talks of equivalence, but more than 700 British soldiers in Northern Ireland were killed by paramilitaries. Not one single paramilitary has been arraigned and taken to court for any of those murders that were committed against the British Army and the British forces. The Secretary of State talks of equivalence, but this is not equivalence, because it is those soldiers who will be persecuted for the rest of time, and not one single member of the paramilitaries, who kept no records, will ever go in front of a court. That is not fair.
I apologise if I have got this wrong, but I do not remember using the word “equivalence”. What I said was that independent prosecutors would make decisions on the basis of the evidence that they had before them. The current legacy commission is able to refer cases for potential prosecution, and the new legacy commission will be able to do the same. If there is evidence that will allow paramilitaries to be prosecuted, it will be for the prosecutors to decide whether to bring a case, and if the right hon. Gentleman cares to look at the convictions that there have been since the Good Friday agreement, he will find that most of them have related to paramilitaries. As I said a moment ago, most of the trials that are currently being awaited relate not to the armed forces but to paramilitaries.
(1 year, 1 month ago)
Commons ChamberI thank my hon. Friend for her question. She is such a strong advocate for the many veterans she represents. I encourage her to look at the legislation to see the nature of the legislative commitments to give effect to the veterans’ protections. There will be a couple that will not be in legislation because they are entirely in our own hands, agreeing a protocol with the commission to ensure that there is no cold calling.
I would like to take this opportunity to welcome my new deputy, the Under-Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, my hon. Friend the Member for Wirral West (Matthew Patrick) to the House. It is very remiss of me not to have done so. This is the first chance we have had to sit together on the Front Bench. I pay tribute to the Minister for the Armed Forces, my hon. Friend the Member for Birmingham Selly Oak (Al Carns), from the Ministry of Defence, who has played a really important and significant role in putting the protections in place. I note that Lieutenant General Sir Nick Pope, the chair of the Confederation of Service Charities, has said that the Confederation
“welcomes the development of the safeguards that have been put in place to offer protection to those within the armed forces community who are affected by legacy issues.”
I, too, welcome that recognition of what we have done.
Obviously the devil lies in the detail in these things, and never more so than in Northern Ireland. Before the Bill comes eventually before us, we really cannot say for certain whether it is good, bad or indifferent, as is often the case.
I will raise two points. First, I will mention the agreement—I find it a little wishy-washy—over Ireland’s role in all this, which, as has been said by my hon. Friends, has a huge amount of history attached to it, given that Ireland has previously refused to hand over people who really were guilty of the most vexatious, disgusting attacks on civilians and soldiers. It does seem to me rather peculiar. We will wait and see what that actually means. Ireland says it is committed—I would love to see what that commitment actually means.
Secondly, I will mention vexatious prosecutions. The note we have here talks about protection from repeated investigations
“unless there are compelling reasons to do so”.
My concern with things like that is that they are little hooks that allow development through legislation, instead of being powerful tools to do what the Secretary of State says. I therefore urge him right now to be very clear when this legislation comes forward that this cannot be broken through and to tie down the definition of “compelling”.
I note the right hon. Gentleman’s point about the past, and I am not going to dissent from what he said, but this is an attempt to move beyond the past and the history and to move forward to something that is better. In the end, people will judge the commitments that this Government and the Irish Government have made, but the deal has been signed in good faith, and we are committed to doing what we promised to do.
The commission was established by the previous Government, after all, and I took the decision not to abolish it, but to reform it. Many people criticised that—they wanted it scrapped completely and for us to start again, but I thought that would have been a mistake, because time waits for no one. We would have wasted all the money and stopped the investigations that are taking place, which are really important to the families. Every single investigation is important to every single family, because each is about the death of a loved one.
I am sure we will debate the specifics of the legislation at length in the House. The state has a duty, of course, to properly investigate cases where it has been involved in a death. The right hon. Gentleman is well aware of that. It is a duty that all of us should uphold.
(1 year, 9 months ago)
Commons ChamberUrgent Questions are proposed each morning by backbench MPs, and up to two may be selected each day by the Speaker. Chosen Urgent Questions are announced 30 minutes before Parliament sits each day.
Each Urgent Question requires a Government Minister to give a response on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
The findings of the coroner in this case stand for themselves and are on the record, and all of us are able to read them. In answer to the hon. Gentleman’s direct question about what the Government are doing, as I indicated to the House in my answer to the right hon. Member for Goole and Pocklington (David Davis), the Ministry of Defence is, of course, giving very serious consideration to what the coroner had to say.
I am astonished by the coroner’s findings. He was not asked to contemplate the question about why—getting inside the head of a soldier who is worried about whether they are going to be shot dead is very difficult. I served in Northern Ireland and some of the decisions that we had to take were instantaneous. There was no time to mull them over—it was either life or death. I lost a very good friend, Captain Robert Nairac. The Secretary of State says that the trouble with the last legacy Act was that it gave immunity to IRA members, but they already had immunity, not just through the letters of comfort but because they kept no records, so they cannot be prosecuted. The only group that will be prosecuted will be soldiers, like myself, who never asked to go to Northern Ireland, but went because we were told to protect civilians, and who served their country. They will be dragged in front of the courts because the Government seem not to care about them.
I say to the right hon. Gentleman, who himself gave distinguished service, that I absolutely understand and recognise the point he forcefully makes about the circumstances in which our soldiers found themselves as part of Operation Banner. They had seen their comrades killed and they did not know what they were going to face; as he rightly says, in those circumstances soldiers had to make very hard split-second decisions.
The coroner had a job to do. He expressed his findings, Members of the House are expressing what they feel about those findings, and the Ministry of Defence is considering them. It is right and proper that we stand by our armed forces, which is why the Government and the Ministry of Defence give support to veterans in those circumstances. However, I would point out that many, many members of the Provisional IRA and the loyalist terrorist organisations were prosecuted, tried and convicted.
(1 year, 11 months ago)
Commons ChamberOn the one inquiry I announced to the House, in relation to the murder of Pat Finucane, I explained the unique circumstances that led me to reach that conclusion. If I may correct the hon. Gentleman, inquiries were never taken off the table as an option. They have remained on the table. It is for the Government of the day to decide whether a public inquiry is ordered or not. He is right that civil cases and inquests in due course will return. It is the case that some people do not have confidence in ICRIR. That is why I think it is important that we should take further steps to try to build that confidence, but I have no doubt about its capacity to do the job that is required on behalf of the families that seek its help. As I made clear in the House previously, in the end, ICRIR’s effectiveness will be judged by those families. Do they get the answers that they have sought for so long by approaching it? I know that Sir Declan Morgan is really committed to making sure that he can do that.
I, like a number of others, served in Northern Ireland. We did not ask to go, and I lost a very good friend there—and others, at the same time. That man’s parents died without ever knowing what had happened to him, but it turns out that he may well have been dismembered and disappeared completely. There is no closure for them, and there is no chance, unless Ireland opens up its books and looks into this, that we will ever get any justice for him. He had a family as well, and many friends who wonder what happened to that brave man, and there are many more like him. So I say on their behalf: yes, let there be justice for families, but let us not forget all those soldiers who will now, in some cases, be hounded for no reason at all—those who lost their friends and their children and who did not want to go there in the first place. Where is the justice for them?
Let me first thank the right hon. Gentleman for his service in Northern Ireland. Let me also say how sad I am to hear about the case that he has just described. Justice information should be—must be —available to all. I would just point out, however, that there are service personnel who lost their lives in the conflict in Northern Ireland who did not support the legacy Act, precisely because it proposed to give immunity to people who had killed their loved ones. That is another reason why I think it is right to remove immunity from the statute book, which the remedial order that I have laid before the House today will do.
(7 years, 7 months ago)
Commons ChamberThe hon. Gentleman makes a really good point, because it was not clear from the Prime Minister’s statement yesterday how the propositions, if the two of them are not able to reach agreement, will be constructed and put to the House. Obviously, we will wait with interest to see what may come out of the discussions taking place today and—who knows?—tomorrow, but it does give the House a chance to interpose in this process. If I were the Leader of the House, I would be enthusiastically supporting amendment (a), because it may well be that votes on Monday will be exactly what is required to take this process forward, whether as a result of something that comes out of the talks or from the House itself.
I am genuinely grateful to the right hon. Gentleman, and I hesitate to correct him, but if he thinks back to what he has just said, he will see that he has made a comparison that does not stand. He compared what happened in the indicative votes with the failure of the Government’s motion. The Government had to get a majority of the House, and they are 48 short of that, whereas not one of the indicative votes got within whispering distance of a majority of the House. Is the right hon. Gentleman suggesting that if the indicative votes process is brought back, each element should meet the requirement of a majority vote of the House?
I was making the much simpler point that none of the propositions has carried. The Prime Minister said in her statement that
“the Government stands ready to abide by the decision of the House.”
That is important. She was referring to the indicative votes that may follow the process that we are currently undertaking. In my view, anything that the House indicates it is prepared to support—the difference is that indicative votes are so called precisely because we ask the House to indicate whether it is prepared to move in a given direction—would have to be considered by the Government. If a proposition were adopted, the Prime Minister would have to go to the European Union and seek to change the political declaration. At that point, it would come back to the House, and the test that the Government rightly set in section 13 of the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018—the approval of the House for both the political declaration and the withdrawal agreement—would have to be passed.