Written Question
Tuesday 7th January 2020
Asked by:
Christopher Chope (Conservative - Christchurch)
Question
to the Attorney General:
To ask the Attorney General, what estimate he has made of the cost to the public purse of the (a) first, (b) second and (c) third prosecution against Mr David Duckenfield on manslaughter in relation to the Hillsborough tragedy; and if he will make a statement.
Answered by Michael Ellis
This was a complex and harrowing case. Every effort was made to build a robust case for prosecution, in accordance with the Code for Crown Prosecutors and the case was handled by a team of experienced specialist prosecutors.
As it involved the prosecution of more than one defendant, it is not possible to state definitively the total costs in relation to the prosecution of David Duckenfield alone. In June 2017, David Duckenfield, the police commander in charge of safety during the Hillsborough stadium disaster, was charged with gross negligence manslaughter. At trial in April 2019, the jury was unable to reach a verdict against David Duckenfield, while a second defendant, Graham Mackrell, was convicted of a health and safety offence. In November 2019, after a retrial at Preston Crown Court, the jury found David Duckenfield not guilty.
The CPS estimates the cost of legal counsel fees and other prosecution costs for the prosecution of both David Duckenfield and Graham Mackrell to be approximately £1.97 million. CPS records do not capture the cost of the time spent by internal CPS staff on this case.
The CPS cannot comment on costs incurred by the police, HM Courts and Tribunals, or any other partners in this case. Nor can the CPS comment on the private prosecution referred to in the question, which was brought against David Duckenfield by the Hillsborough Family Support Group in 2000.
Speech in Commons Chamber - Wed 25 Sep 2019
Legal Advice: Prorogation
"Did it come as a surprise to my right hon. and learned Friend that the Supreme Court ruled that the act of Prorogation was not a proceeding in Parliament? If that is the new law to which he has referred, would it be open to Parliament to change the law …..."Christopher Chope - View Speech
View all Christopher Chope (Con - Christchurch) contributions to the debate on: Legal Advice: Prorogation
Speech in Commons Chamber - Fri 29 Mar 2019
United Kingdom’s Withdrawal from the European Union
"Will my right hon. and learned Friend give way?..."Christopher Chope - View Speech
View all Christopher Chope (Con - Christchurch) contributions to the debate on: United Kingdom’s Withdrawal from the European Union
Speech in Commons Chamber - Fri 29 Mar 2019
United Kingdom’s Withdrawal from the European Union
"I will be joining the hon. Member for Leicester West (Liz Kendall) in voting against this agreement. Despite the best interests of so many of my colleagues, I fear they are falling for the Government’s siren song that is threatening no Brexit or an even softer Brexit as the only …..."Christopher Chope - View Speech
View all Christopher Chope (Con - Christchurch) contributions to the debate on: United Kingdom’s Withdrawal from the European Union
Speech in Commons Chamber - Mon 03 Dec 2018
Withdrawal Agreement: Legal Position
"My right hon. and learned Friend told my right hon. Friend the Member for Preseli Pembrokeshire (Stephen Crabb) that the European Union is refusing to allow a get-out clause on the permanent backstop, but he has also told us that he does not believe that the permanent backstop is sound …..."Christopher Chope - View Speech
View all Christopher Chope (Con - Christchurch) contributions to the debate on: Withdrawal Agreement: Legal Position
Speech in Commons Chamber - Thu 29 Nov 2018
Withdrawal Agreement: Legal Advice
"Can my hon. and learned Friend confirm that, as every lawyer knows, advice depends on the quality of the questions sought? Can he therefore assure us that he or our right hon. and learned Friend the Attorney General will set out on Monday all the questions in respect of which …..."Christopher Chope - View Speech
View all Christopher Chope (Con - Christchurch) contributions to the debate on: Withdrawal Agreement: Legal Advice
Speech in Commons Chamber - Thu 14 Apr 2016
Oral Answers to Questions
"Does my right hon. and learned Friend’s position take account of the European Court of Justice ruling on 5 April, which effectively drives a coach and horses through the whole of the arrest warrant procedure because it makes it clear that the European Court of Justice is in charge of …..."Christopher Chope - View Speech
View all Christopher Chope (Con - Christchurch) contributions to the debate on: Oral Answers to Questions
Speech in Commons Chamber - Thu 25 Feb 2016
Oral Answers to Questions
"Under the Lisbon treaty, the European Union has a treaty obligation to join the European convention on human rights. However, the European Court of Justice has said that that would be incompatible with EU law. Does that not demonstrate that the European Court of Justice is, indeed, supreme?..."Christopher Chope - View Speech
View all Christopher Chope (Con - Christchurch) contributions to the debate on: Oral Answers to Questions
Speech in Commons Chamber - Thu 25 Feb 2016
Oral Answers to Questions
"What are the Government doing to reduce the economic inequality caused by gender differences in life expectancy?..."Christopher Chope - View Speech
View all Christopher Chope (Con - Christchurch) contributions to the debate on: Oral Answers to Questions
Speech in Commons Chamber - Thu 14 Jan 2016
Oral Answers to Questions
"Will my hon. Friend explain why this is not part of the Government’s renegotiation strategy? Surely this country and this Parliament should be able to decide levels of VAT not just on sanitary products, but on fuel, defibrillators and so on—on all of which I think it would be better …..."Christopher Chope - View Speech
View all Christopher Chope (Con - Christchurch) contributions to the debate on: Oral Answers to Questions