Housing: Underoccupancy Charge

Baroness Sherlock Excerpts

Monday 20th January 2014 Lords Chamber

[Baroness Sherlock (Lab)]

My Lords, the Minister has failed to address the core point made by my noble friend Lady Hollis and the noble Lord, Lord Best: why are the Government penalising people already in social housing, who took out their contracts when the current system was in place and before the bedroom tax came in? Why could they not protect people, as this House asked them to do during the passage of the Welfare Reform Act? If all else fails, will he join us in our costed commitment to abolish the bedroom tax?

[Lord Freud]

My Lords, the costings of the Labour Party in this area are fairly extreme because it seems to have used the same money many times over. This is a savings measure introduced in the emergency Budget, which applies to the existing case load and gives 33 months’ notice. The comparison is with the LHA changes introduced at the same time, for which there was less notice: 21 to 33 months. We have put in as support the discretionary housing payment system, as opposed to transitional protection.