High-control Religious Groups: Support for Victims Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateAlex Davies-Jones
Main Page: Alex Davies-Jones (Labour - Pontypridd)Department Debates - View all Alex Davies-Jones's debates with the Ministry of Justice
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Commons ChamberI congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for North West Cambridgeshire (Sam Carling) on securing this important debate and shining a light on the experiences of people who have suffered abuse in high-control religious groups. He is right to say that the issue does not fit neatly in one Government Department. It is on all of us to do better, to be aware of the issues faced by vulnerable individuals fleeing those organisations, and to recognise that what they are suffering is abuse, and that they are victims.
For someone who has spent their life in one of those environments, finding the courage to leave can mean, as my hon. Friend the Member for Spen Valley (Kim Leadbeater) said, risking everything they have ever known: their family, friends community, and the support networks they rely on. Nobody should have to choose between their freedom and the people they love. But for too many people in our country, that is sadly their reality.
Freedom of faith and belief is, of course, a fundamental right, and this Government and I will always defend it, but that freedom must never be used as a shield for coercion, exploitation or abuse. The right to practise one’s faith must go hand in hand with the right, if one so chooses, to leave it.
We know, however, that leaving a high-control group rarely means simply walking out of a door. It often means someone leaving behind their entire world, facing profound trauma and complete social isolation. Even after someone has escaped, their ordeal may be far from over. The trauma of what they have experienced can remain with them for years, and finding the right support can be another enormous challenge. We know that those experiences do not always fit neatly into the categories that support services are designed around. That means that victims struggle to find the help they need at precisely the moment they need it most. We must do better at recognising those experiences and making sure that survivors can access appropriate support.
As my hon. Friend the Member for North West Cambridgeshire will be aware, this Government have proudly committed over £550 million for victim and witness support services over the next three years. That is the largest investment in victim support to date. At a local level, police and crime commissioners are able to allocate funding based on their assessment of need, including funding for specialist organisations and therapeutic support. We are also providing a 2% uplift, year on year, to reflect the fact that it sadly now costs more to deliver support services. We cannot stand still; we must continue listening closely to survivors, victims, frontline charities—some of which have been mentioned in this debate—and Members across this House to ensure that the system truly captures every victim and survivor. Let me be clear: where criminal behaviour is suspected, it must be reported to the police, and it is never too late for a survivor to come forward.
We must be alive to the fact that high-control religious settings can sadly be a gateway to other forms of abuse. It is deeply harrowing to hear affected victims’ accounts of modern slavery and exploitation. High-control religious settings and isolated communities can create acute vulnerabilities to trafficking, forced labour, domestic servitude and even sexual exploitation. For some survivors, escaping those environments is sadly only the beginning. They may need immediate protection from even further exploitation, violence or harm. When someone has been subject to modern slavery, specialist support is available through the national referral mechanism.
Frontline responders, whether the police, local councils, or specialist charities, have a clear duty to identify victims, ensure their cases are referred to the police, and connect them with vital support. For adults, including those carrying the trauma of childhood exploitation, the modern slavery victim care contract can also provide dedicated, specialist recovery support. For children, we all have an even greater duty of care. There is statutory local authority support, and alongside that, independent child trafficking guardians stand beside young victims to guide them through a daunting and scary process. We have recently committed £25 million to roll out this service nationally by next summer, and, through the Immigration and Asylum Bill, we are placing the provision of these guardians on a statutory footing for the very first time, guaranteeing that no trafficked child has to navigate their recovery alone.
One of the most disturbing aspects of the experiences we have heard about tonight is the way that coercion can gradually strip someone of their independence—their freedom to make their own decisions, their control over their own life, and, ultimately, that vital sense of who they are. That is why the criminal law rightly recognises the severe damage of controlling or coercive behaviour, whether or not it is accompanied by physical violence. I want to reassure my hon. Friend that I will ensure that the Minister with responsibility for safeguarding, my hon. Friend the Member for Southampton Test (Satvir Kaur), meets him and the Family Survival Trust to discuss what more can be done in this area of law.
I also want to address the deeply concerning practice of mandated shunning in high-control religious groups. As we have heard, shunning is when a community enforces total social exclusion, which can act as a powerful mechanism of control that traps people in harm and trauma. When someone knows that speaking out or leaving means losing their family, their home and their entire support network, it can have devastating consequences, including compelling women to stay in abusive marriages.
Shunning can never excuse or shield abuse. Where it occurs in domestic and family settings, we are taking decisive action. Last year, we rolled out Raneem’s law, which embeds independent domestic abuse specialists directly in 999 control rooms, so that victims get the right response from the very first call. We have established the national centre for violence against women and girls and public protection, backed this year by a further £13.9 million. We have also committed more than £53 million over four years to expand the Drive project across England and Wales, which confronts high-harm, serial perpetrators head-on, so that the burden of achieving safety no longer falls on the victim. Again, I hear my hon. Friend when he says that this applies only to domestic or intimate partner relationships; that is why I am committed to meeting him and relevant organisations to discuss the harm that he outlines.
It is equally unacceptable that anyone in Britain today should be subjected to abuse simply because of who they are. Listening to accounts of so-called conversion practices is deeply troubling and appalling. Through our draft conversion practices Bill, we are setting clear, robust thresholds to ensure that these harmful practices are rightly criminalised. Because this is a sensitive and complex area, we welcome thorough pre-legislative scrutiny to ensure that the law is watertight and protects those at risk without having unintended consequences. However, we need to be clear that these practices are harmful and wrong, and we will make them illegal.
I am conscious of time, Madam Deputy Speaker. In closing, I thank my hon. Friend the Member for North West Cambridgeshire once again for securing this important debate and for shining the light on an issue that is normally in the shadows—something that we do not hear about in the mainstream; something that is talked about in hushed tones, in private conversations in private communities. The stories shared across the House tonight are a powerful reminder that psychological coercion, isolation and exploitation leave scars that can last a lifetime.
Nobody should have to choose between their freedom and the people they love, and nobody who finds the courage to leave an abusive environment should ever be left to rebuild their life alone. Survivors and victims deserve to be heard, taken seriously and treated with dignity, and to know that the support they need will be there for them. Escaping abuse should be the beginning of a new life, not the beginning of yet another struggle to be recognised and supported. We have a responsibility to all victims and survivors to ensure that that is the case, and it is a responsibility that this Government take extremely seriously.
Question put and agreed to.