1 Lord Walker of Broxton debates involving HM Treasury

Autumn Budget 2026

Lord Walker of Broxton Excerpts
Thursday 12th November 2026

(4 days, 8 hours ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Walker of Broxton Portrait Lord Walker of Broxton (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I declare an interest as executive chairman of Iceland Foods.

In March, I told this House that our Victorian business rates system remains badly out of kilter between bricks-and-mortar retailers and online giants. I even suggested an online sales tax, and I say that as the chairman of one of the largest online food retailers in the UK. My point then, as now, is simple: we need a fairer system that encourages businesses to invest in our towns, rather than penalising them for being there. High streets are the beating heart of communities. When they thrive, local economies thrive; when they wither, something vital is lost.

I welcome the Chancellor’s decision to remove business rates for another 70,000 smaller businesses, the Secretary of State’s paper Hope on the High Street and the £210 million community assets programme. Bringing public services back into town centres, giving councils powers over empty properties and tackling crime are all sensible steps. However, we cannot regenerate high streets simply by improving what surrounds the shops while also making those shops more expensive to run.

Iceland still trades in the towns that many other retailers have abandoned. I see those high streets every week. Our stores provide affordable food, local jobs and a reason to visit. A post office, pharmacy or convenience store can be the difference between a high street with customers and one that is slowly dying. Retail is not an optional extra; it is the economic engine that makes everything else possible.

For businesses that do not qualify for the new exemption, the real-terms freeze, which has been mentioned many times, still allows bills to rise with inflation. Indeed, the British Retail Consortium estimates another £250 million in rates costs by next April. That is hardly the relief larger retailers—the ones who still anchor town centres and provide the bulk of employment—were looking for. Business rates, employer national insurance and energy costs all weigh on the same decision: whether to open, to invest and to employ—or to pull down the shutters. These are not abstract numbers; they decide whether a high street stays alive.

I welcome energy support for manufacturers, but retailers, especially those with refrigerated supply chains, use large amounts of electricity too. Why recognise the disadvantages in manufacturing yet offer no equivalent support to retail? Progress on VAT collection by online marketplaces is also welcome. Fair competition starts with everyone paying the taxes they owe. However, it still does not answer the fundamental question: how do we create a fair balance between physical and predominantly online businesses? I am not wedded to any particular tax; I simply want the system to reflect how retail works today, not how it worked in the 19th century.

As well as filling up empty buildings, Ministers should judge regeneration on whether businesses are investing, jobs are being created and town centres are places where people want to spend their time and their money. I therefore ask the Minister to look again at three things: first, the unremitting cost of running high street businesses; secondly, extending energy support beyond manufacturing; thirdly, a clear timetable for fundamental business rate reform. We are now heading in the right direction, but our high streets and the communities that depend on them deserve more—more fairness, more ambition and more urgency.