Found: Lord Mance made that point.

Found: Before the Law Commission, we had Lord Hoffmann, Lord Mance, Lord Phillips, Sir Richard Aikens, Sir

Found: back, maybe it is not wise to obsess too much about that legacy and keep in mind the wise words of Lord

Found: We also agree with Lord Mance that “[i]t is wrong for a tribunal’s analysis of its own jurisdiction

Found: By way of final point, we also agree with Lord Mance that the new court rules should ensure that

Found: We respectfully share the views expressed by Lord Mance on that issue during the debates.5 As expressed

Found: jurisdiction by the courts, the key issue to consider is what was stated by both Lord Verdirame and Lord

Found: The Chair: You have obviously read what Lord Mance said in the Second Reading debate about the fundamental

Found: Lord Mance and J Turner Privy Council Practice (Oxford: OUP, 2017) at [6.33]. 18 Obergefell v Hodges

Found: Lord Mance and J Turner Privy Council Practice (Oxford: OUP, 2017) at [6.33]. 18 Obergefell v Hodges

Found: While the Committee is not bound by the decisions of the Supreme Court, the words of Lord Mance JSC

Found: My predecessor, Lord Mance, wrote to you on 23 March 2020 to say that consultation had revealed “significant

Found: and Conway cases emphasised in their speeches that Parliament should now take forward this issue: Lord

Found: Following Lord Woolf’s stepping down, Lord Mance, a former UK Supreme Court Judge has taken over

Found: As Lord Mance has said, ‘the European Convention on Human Rights incorporates requirements that any

Found: As Lord Mance, former Justice of the Supreme Court, has recently noted, this dialogue has seen UK courts

Found: Alyson Kilpatrick: Various people, including Lord Mance and Lady Hale, have used cases from Northern

Found: Lord Mance has said that this “ignores the difference between first instance access to justice and

Found: Q96 Dr Mullan: Are you concerned by people like Lord Dyson, Lord Mance and senior retired judges

Found: In Lady Hale’s judgment (with whom Lord Mance, Lord Kerr and Lady Black agreed), she specifically

Found: As Lord Mance stated in Nicklinson: “even though I fully accept, that, while the legislature is there

Found: Moreover, a s Lord Mance set out in evidence to us, the application of the ECHR rights via the HRA

Found: You may recall Lord Mance commenting on how the law on access to abortion in Northern Ireland was in

Found: continuing UK EU membership, by subsequent rulings of the Supreme Court, for example in the judgment of Lord

Found: Lord Mance told us that the fiUnited Kingdom courts have been, and are increasingly, successful in in

Found: Last week, we took evidence from Lord Mance, whom you will know well, and from a number of legal academicsŠProfessor

Found: HRR0002 - Human Rights Act Reform Lord Mance Written Evidence

Found: Human Rights Act Reform Lord Mance, former Deputy President of the Supreme Court , Professor Alison

Found: in paragraphs 22 and 23, above, were put to the House on 8 July 2020, and in presenting the report Lord

Found: Court of the United Kingdom, University of Cambridge, Glasgow University, and Newcastle University Lord

Found: I have already given a hint of what my view is.Elizabeth Prochaska: I cannot do better than Lord Mance

Found: 26 January 2022 Lord Mance (Former Justice at The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom), Professor Alison

Found: Any Other Business For information only: • Letter from Lord Mance to Tom Brake, Unlock Democracy

Found: However, Lord Mance in his celebrated Oxford Shrieval lecture in 2011 observed that fiThe infinite circumstances

Found: Mance beyond January 2022, (2) how the peers who would remain on the Committee should be selected ,

Found: member) Andrea Coomber (lay member) Dr Vanessa Davies (lay member) Baroness Donaghy Baroness Hussein-Ece Lord

Found: member) Andrea Coomber (lay member) Dr Vanessa Davies (lay member) Baroness Donaghy Baroness Hussein-Ece Lord

Found: A paper from the Clerk (COND/21- 22/22) RESTRICTED To take note: Letter from Baroness Jay to Lord

Found: member) Andrea Coomber (lay member) Dr Vanessa Davies (lay member) Baroness Donaghy Baroness Hussein-Ece Lord

Found: member) Andrea Coomber (lay member) Dr Vanessa Davies (lay member) Baroness Donaghy Baroness Hussein-Ece Lord

Found: member) Andrea Coomber (lay member) Dr Vanessa Davies (lay member) Baroness Donaghy Baroness Hussein-Ece Lord

Found: As Lord Mance pointed out in Doherty v Birmingham [2009] 1 AC 367, para 126, section 2 of the HRA requires

Found: In a judicial review on abortion law by the NIHRC, Lord Mance noted there was no indication when or

Found: member) Andrea Coomber (lay member) Dr Vanessa Davies (lay member) Baroness Donaghy Baroness Hussein-Ece Lord

Found: Five Justices (Lord Neuberger, Lady Hale, Lord Mance, Lord Kerr and Lord Wilson) hold that the court

Found: criminal"), affirmed in Pham v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2015] UKSC 19 at [97]-[98] (Lord

Found: complaints about Lord Kilclooney’s comments to be within her remit , the Lord Speaker shou ld write to Lord

Found: complaints about Lord Kilclooney’s comments to be within her remit , the Lord Speaker should write to Lord

Found: Memorandum by the Clerk to the Conduct Committee and the Lords ICGS Implementation Lead , and Letter from Lord

Found: Mance, Chair of the Conduct Committee, to the Lord Speaker C/19-21/52 HIGHLY RESTRICTED The Clerk

Found: ) at page 5, final paragraph, see also the speeches of Lord Wilson JSC (at paragraphs 10 to 22) and Lord

Found: The question related to my reaction and comment on the remarks made by Lord Mance in the House of

Found: In his interventions in the debates thus f ar, Lord Mance has given some very powerful warnings against

Found: having equal worth in human terms as a nondisabled child', referencing comments by Baroness Hale, Lord

Found: h aving equal worth in human terms as a nondisabled child', referencin g comments by Baroness Hale, Lord

Found: February 2020.43 Sugar v BBC [2012] UKSC 444 Kennedy v The Charity Commission [2014] UKSC 2045 [94], Lord

Found: February 2020.108 Sugar v BBC [2012] UKSC 4109 Kennedy v The Charity Commission [2014] UKSC 20110 [94], Lord

Found: h aving equal worth in human terms as a nondisabled child', referencin g comments by Baroness Hale, Lord

Found: The Lord Speaker explained that he had spoken with Lord Mance, Chairman of the Conduct Committee about

Question

To ask the Senior Deputy Speaker what was the recruitment process for the lay members of the Conduct Committee; how many people applied for each lay member vacancy; who conducted the interviews for these positions; and what remuneration the lay members receive.

Answered by Lord Gardiner of Kimble

I have consulted the Chair of the Conduct Committee in preparing this answer.

The four lay members of the Conduct Committee were appointed following an open and rigorous recruitment process. In common with other senior, lay member or non-executive positions, the House engaged a recruitment consultancy to conduct a search and initial sift of candidates. A total of 322 candidates were identified through this process. Of these, 12 were invited to interview by a panel consisting of two members of the Conduct Committee (Lord Mance, Chair, and Baroness Anelay of St Johns), the then Clerk of the Journals and two external members (Sheila Drew Smith and Emily Jackson), with the four top-ranked candidates accepting the offer of appointment. Lay members are remunerated at the rate of £600 per eight hour day.

Found: 2002) Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood* Law Lord (2004-09) Oct 2009 - April 2012 2 years Retirement Lord

Found: At the same time, chairmanship of the committee passed from the Senior Deputy Speaker to Lord Mance.

?️"There are times when the European Convention on Human Rights has been the necessary inspiration for the development of domestic law: e.g. the lifting of the ban on homosexuals in the armed forces & the ending of detention without trial" ~ Lord Mance ?:https://t.co/wTnUUHmN0n https://t.co/WvChq80cBg

?Our session on the #HumanRightsAct begins with our Deputy Chair, @joannaccherry, welcoming our panel of witnesses: Lord Mance, Professor Alison Young, Dr Hélène Tyrrell @DrHeleneTyrrell and Professor Adam Tomkins @ProfTomkins. ?Watch live here: https://t.co/wTnUUHmN0n

?Tomorrow at 3pm we will be questioning former Supreme Court Justice Lord Mance, Professor Alison Young, Dr Hélène Tyrrell, and Professor Adam Tomkins on the proposed reforms to the #HumanRightsAct. ?Read the news article: https://t.co/1kNcPaJr2T https://t.co/ccAyH3WEAc

Found: Hodge, The Rt Hon Lord Briggs of Westbourne, The Rt Hon Lady Arden of Heswall DBE, The Rt Hon The Lord

Found: Lord Mance, latterly Deputy President of the Court, served in the Appellate Committee of the House

Found: At §25, Lord Mance summarised the case law arising under the 1998 Act on the same language

Found: should be certain, so that it can be easily enforced and so that peop le can know where they standfl: Lord

Found: But, Lord Mance and Lady Hale nonetheless joined Lords Neuberger, Kerr and Reed in quashing the Attorney

Found: As Lord Mance observed in Stott [229], the concept of status should be construed broadly, but not every

Found: Affairs (Sea Fish Industry Authority intervening) [2011] UKSC 25; [2011] 1 WLR 1546 , para 10, Lord

Found: International Ltd v Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs [2011] 1 WLR 1546, para 10, Lord

Found: should be certain, so that it can be easily enforced and so that peop le can know where they standfl: Lord

Found: Food and Rural A ff airs (Sea Fish Industry Authority intervening) [2011] 1 WLR 1546, para 10, Lord

Found: On the other hand, in Helow , Lord Mance expressed a note of caution on th e issue of disclosure

Found: A s to FG Hemisphere , at paragraph 16 Lord Mance had stated (with bold emphasis added): determining

Found: Litigation ensued and, in Gaines - Cooper , the Supreme Court held (Lord Mance dissenting) that

Found: investigated : the Arnold case, para 77 citing In re Sigma Finance Corpn [2010] 1 All ER 571 , para 12, per Lord

Found: Hodge, The Rt Hon Lord Briggs of Westbourne, The Rt Hon Lady Arden of Heswall DBE, The Rt Hon The Lord

Found: liaison with the Lord Chancellor’s Advisory Committee on Private International Law (PIL), chaired by Lord

Found: The Lord Mance PC; Northern Ireland: The Rt. Hon Sir Declan Morgan QC, The Hon.

Found: At §25, Lord Mance summarised the case law arising under the 1998 Act on the same language

Found: BridgesInterim Chair, Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (IPSA)Director of Regulation, IPSA Lord

Found: Home Department ex parte Bugdaycay [1987] AC 514 at 531 and, more recently, the observations of Lord

Found: ascertained and at the logic of the inferences drawn from them. ” Page | 14 Drawing on those authorities, Lord

Found: Medical Costs for Asbestos Diseases (Wales) Bill [2015] UKSC 3, [2015] AC 1016 (“Welsh Asbestos case ”) Lord

Found: Medical Costs for Asbestos Diseases (Wales) Bill [2015] UKSC 3, [2015] AC 1016 (“Welsh Asbestos case ”) Lord

Found: the judgment of Baroness Hale (with whom Lord Kerr of Tonaghmore, Lord Hodge, Lady Black JJSC, and Lord