15 Lord Macdonald of River Glaven debates involving the Ministry of Justice

Tue 10th Nov 2026
Courts and Tribunals Bill
Lords Chamber

Committee stage part one
Tue 27th Oct 2026
Wed 8th Nov 2023
Mon 15th Nov 2021
Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill
Lords Chamber

Lords Hansard - Part 1 & Committee stage: Part 1
Mon 8th Feb 2021
Domestic Abuse Bill
Lords Chamber

Committee stage:Committee: 5th sitting (Hansard) & Committee: 5th sitting (Hansard) & Committee: 5th sitting (Hansard): House of Lords
Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, the backlogs are now so great, and the delays in trials taking place so vast, that we are talking about cases being listed two or three years in the future, which is a hopeless situation for witnesses, victims, complainants and, of course, defendants. Some sort of structural change is necessary, but the question is what form it should take.

As I made clear at Second Reading, I do not have a difficulty with courts making the decision about where cases should be allocated, rather than defendants. In fact, granting defendants that right is comparatively unusual across the common-law world and does not even exist universally across the United Kingdom. It is not the system that pertains in Scotland, and I imagine your Lordships would all agree that Scotland has a civilised, decent and fair legal system—that is certainly my view, as someone whose parents were natives of Scotland.

My concern, however, as I expressed at Second Reading, is whether the magistrates’ courts can cope with the new levels of work that they are going to receive. I entirely agree with the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson of Liverpool, that it is not simply a lack of funding or the Covid pandemic that have caused the backlogs—although lack of funding has been a very significant contributor, and Governments of all persuasions have deliberately starved the justice system of cash because it was an easy target, and it is obviously true that Covid played its part. As the noble and learned Lord said, the increasing complexity of criminal trials and the bulk of evidence—CCTV evidence, DNA evidence, scientific evidence and all the rest of it—have made trials longer and contributed to the backlog.

The obvious flaw in that argument, however, when it comes to the Government’s proposed reform, is this: why would those cases be any less complicated in the magistrates’ court? How is the magistrates’ court to cope with the increasing complexity? There is no doubt at all that most of our magistrates’ courts in greater urban areas are presently in a state of chaos: the backlogs are enormous and growing; we are failing to recruit sufficient magistrates; and we do not have enough district judges. Unless we significantly increase the number of magistrates and district judges, magistrates’ courts will simply be unable to cope with the increased volume and complexity of work that is destined for those courts because of this legislation. The Government are going to have to devote significant funding to this change if it is to work.

All these issues make even more important Amendment 2, in the names of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas, and other noble Lords, on the question of allocation. It is going to be critical that magistrates’ courts have some allocation guidelines in this area. If not, there is an obvious risk—I speak as someone who knows a number of magistrates—that magistrates simply continue to send everything up to the Crown Court because their courts cannot cope. That will happen if there is not some form of allocation and increased funding for the magistrates’ courts. I do not say any of this with great pleasure. Funding has played a major part in the situation in which we find ourselves, and the lack of funding on the part of many Governments has been reprehensible.

Finally, I cannot support Amendment 1. Why should people of good character have more rights in our justice system than people of bad character? I practised in the criminal courts regularly for almost 40 years. I do not any more; I last did a trial in 2012. Why should defendants of bad character have fewer rights when it comes to allocation? I say this frankly and with due respect to them, but most of the defendants who I represented over my 30 or 40 years at the criminal Bar were people of bad character. I never felt that they should have fewer rights in the criminal justice system than people of good character, but that is what Amendment 1 proposes, and I am surprised that it does so. Allocation should apply according to fair and rational guidelines, regardless of the character of the individual who is being allocated.

Baroness Levitt Portrait Baroness Levitt (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I speak in support of Clause 1. At its heart, this clause raises a simple question: do we trust magistrates? Throughout my professional life, I have regarded magistrates as one of the great strengths of our criminal justice system. Every single day, magistrates determine guilt. They pass sentence and make decisions that affect liberty, livelihoods and futures. If they can be trusted to do that, why can they not be trusted to decide where a case should be tried? That is the question I have yet to hear satisfactorily answered by the opponents of Clause 1.

Some argue that magistrates may underestimate the seriousness of a case. My experience suggests the opposite; magistrates frequently err on the side of caution. Indeed, many cases sent to the Crown Court ultimately result in sentences that magistrates themselves could have imposed. If there is a tendency, it broadly appears to be towards caution, not recklessness. With respect to my noble friend Lady Chakrabarti—with whom I agree on almost everything, but not on this occasion—I am slightly mystified by the suggestion that magistrates are going to keep the person of good character in a magistrates’ court but send a serial shoplifter to the Crown Court. My instinct is that rather the opposite is likely to happen. I could not agree more with the noble Lord, Lord Macdonald, that all those who appear before the courts must be treated in exactly the same way.

I am a strong supporter of jury trial; it is one of the strengths of our constitution. However, it does not follow that every case capable of being tried by a jury must be tried by a jury. If that were the principle, the vast majority of criminal cases presently heard by magistrates would need to be transferred back to the Crown Court, and nobody is sensibly arguing for that. Magistrates’ courts do not provide some lesser form of justice, and lay magistrates, like jurors, are members of the public performing a public duty; both reflect the principle that justice should not be administered exclusively by professionals.

As has been frequently said at Second Reading and during this debate, more than 90% of criminal cases are dealt with in the magistrates’ court, and without lay magistrates the system simply would not function. Throughout my career, I have seen magistrates approach difficult cases conscientiously, thoughtfully and fairly. They have earned the confidence of judges, practitioners and the communities which they serve, and they have earned the confidence of Parliament as well. Clause 1 does not ask the magistrates to undertake some radical new judicial function. It asks Parliament to trust them with a decision that is modest when compared with the responsibilities they already discharge every day. The real question is not whether magistrates are ready for this responsibility; it is whether we are prepared to recognise the responsibility they already shoulder.

--- Later in debate ---
Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames Portrait Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, having listened to the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, I have very little to say on reclassification. I said on the last group that I see no argument that can be mounted to suggest that the borderline between summary-only offences and “either way” offences is unchanging. Of course, everybody sensibly accepts that there are some “either way” offences that could be summary-only. That brings about a need to consider reclassification, as the noble and learned Lord described.

I will speak to my Amendment 51 on out-of-court resolutions. At Second Reading, I pointed out that the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, had devoted his first substantive chapter and the first 10 recommendations in his first report to the importance of reaching out-of-court resolutions. His aim was to take low-level criminal offences that could properly be addressed with therapeutic and cautionary responses, aimed at diverting those offences out of the criminal justice system altogether, and address the issues that caused people to commit such offences in the first place. Indeed, he entitled that chapter “Diversions”. That is the issue I seek to address.

At Second Reading, I took as an example the prosecution of parents in unauthorised absence offences under the Education Act 1996, by which parents can be—and are frequently—prosecuted for not ensuring that their children attend school. Very often, the background is that those children are traumatised or unwell and refusing to go to school, however hard the parents, who are the ones ultimately prosecuted, try to get them there. That process and the discord in the home cause real trauma. The prosecutions that result end up in fines that are often unpaid and, in extreme cases, they can result in prison sentences. Often, parents and whole families are dreadfully affected by the process. Many are driven entirely out of the school system and find themselves relying, often unsuitably, on home schooling, or attempts at home schooling, to replace that dreadful cycle. In those cases, what is needed is a constructive and therapeutic approach that helps families with the causes of the non-attendance and addresses the health and social issues causing the damage. So it is with a vast number and range of cases of low-level crime.

In answer to the intervention in the last group, I talked about the cases of low-level crime that went before the magistrates. Many of those cases are suitable not for the criminal justice system at all but for diversions and out-of-court resolution. Many cases of minor dishonesty, including low-level shoplifting, now often do not even get to court because there are not the resources for the prosecution to proceed. A lot of cases of low-level violence, criminal damage and drug and alcohol offences can be dealt with by way of diversion, partly because they originate not in real criminality but in inadequacy or social and personal difficulties.

The noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, looked at and discussed rehabilitation programmes for drug and alcohol abuse. I hesitate to address your Lordships in his presence, when he wrote the report on which I am relying, but the point is that he looked at other health intervention programmes to prevent people being brought into a life of criminality. At the centre of his thinking in this part of his report—he will correct me if I am wrong—was the view, widely accepted by experts in the field and by those in this House who are expert in these areas, that if we can divert people away from low-level crime by addressing the issues that cause them to commit offences then we can encourage rehabilitation and avoid future crime by providing early help. That, of itself, has a huge societal benefit.

The noble and learned Lord’s report and recommendations were addressed chiefly to encouraging the police and the Crown Prosecution Service to divert cases to out-of-court resolutions before they ever get to court, even before charges are laid. We fully support that. Yet there is nothing in the Bill on that. I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Lemos, for engaging with me and others in discussing this, and for addressing the issue sympathetically at Second Reading, when he said that these are matters that we can discuss. It is very important that we do so.

My Amendment 51 is proposed on the basis that it is not only before charges are laid that out-of-court resolution should be considered but that, even when the criminal process has been commenced, diversion and out-of-court resolution should be explored. If it were not the case that we were going to say, in a defeatist way, that it is too late, we would not then see so many cases in our courts when an intelligent observer feels bound to ask, “Why is this defendant here?” And not only an intelligent observer—the same question is routinely asked even by police officers, as well as by probation officers, families, friends and social workers.

My amendment therefore bites on the first time that a person charged with an offence is required to indicate a plea. Indeed, it would impose a duty on those responsible for prosecutions to consider those prosecutions before the first time the defendant is asked to plead. Clearly, of course, many cases will not be suitable for out-of-court resolution, but the report of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, and my amendment are based on the proposition that many are, and that greater resort to out-of-court resolutions has the potential to save many from continuing criminality.

The report of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, was concerned with reducing the case load in the courts and reducing the backlogs. That was his original target. However, his report needs to be read much more widely than that. Initially, the reduction in the case load would come in the magistrates’ courts because we would be talking about low-level crime, but it would filter up to the Crown Court, as all experience tells us that a life of crime starts with minor offences that are charged, tried and sentenced in the magistrates’ court but continued offending gets worse. We hear about prisons being academies of crime. Whether or not that is the case, the fact is that lives of crime tend to get worse as they go on, and it is the failure to adopt out-of-court resolutions for those cases where early help and early intervention could divert people out of the criminal justice system that is responsible for part of that.

In this amendment our ambition is large: we are trying to stimulate a crime reduction programme born of a rethink of the way that we resort to the criminal justice system—a rethink that is radical and potentially of great social benefit. This amendment is a modest step on that road. It is inspired by the concentration of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, on this aspect. It has the prospect of reducing case loads, but also of reducing crime, focusing our attention on the causes of crime and preventing lives being wasted.

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, the noble Lord—wrongly, in my view—disagreed with part of my earlier speech so I want to say how much I agree with his Amendment 51 and with what he has been saying for the last 10 minutes or so.

This is important for all the reasons that the noble Lord has outlined, particularly in breaking a pattern of crime and offending that starts with that first court appearance, and in freeing up space in the magistrates’ courts, which we are told are going to be taking on more serious and more complex cases. He is absolutely right. We all know there are far too many people with addiction issues and mental health issues within the criminal justice system, which is ill suited to deal with them. Much the same could be said about our prison system.

I put in one further plea. A few years ago, in about 2012, I was a member of something called the Independent Commission on Youth Crime and Antisocial Behaviour. We recommended and proposed to the then Government that a programme of restorative justice be implemented across the country. We called and heard a lot of evidence, and went to a number of jurisdictions where restorative justice programmes were in effect. These were wonderfully successful in stopping crime, satisfying the victims of crime and saving the criminal justice system the trouble of trying cases which did not really need to be tried. The noble Lord and this amendment have my full support.

--- Later in debate ---
As a result of the recommendations from the noble and learned Lord, Lord Bellamy, who recommended a substantial increase for criminal defence solicitors, a recommendation was accepted in part. But we all know something about the rise in the cost of living and inflation, and it appears that, since that increase was made, criminal defence work in the magistrates’ court remains scarcely viable, with substantial difficulties of recruitment, training and retention. It therefore seems to us essential to put in the Bill a provision about legal aid, or to require the Government to do something about it. If we do not, we face making the system in the magistrates’ courts one where there will be no legal representation. That is inefficient, and it is not in the interests of justice because, if the more serious cases are to be retained in the magistrates’ courts, they need proper legal representation. I beg to move.
Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, first, I agree with the noble and learned Lord that this is a critical amendment. In my limited experience of sitting as a recorder, there is nothing a judge hates more, or fears more, than a litigant in person, because it makes the case longer, more difficult and more complex to manage. I commend to your Lordships a recent paper published by the Nuffield Family Justice Observatory on the impact of litigants in person in the family courts relying on AI for their pleadings and arguments and refusing to accept the rulings and judgments of judges on the basis that Claude says something different. I would foresee a quite chaotic situation in the magistrates’ court were there to be an absence of lawyers to represent defendants facing terms of imprisonment.

The noble and learned Lord is quite right that, if there is a disparity in payment between the magistrates’ court and the Crown Court, those who currently have mixed practices will stop going to the magistrates’ court and people will stop practising in the magistrates’ court. I suggest strongly to the Government that the sort of equalisation of fees that this amendment speaks to is absolutely essential if their reforms are to work.

Lord Shamash Portrait Lord Shamash (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I declare an interest as a founding partner of Edwards Duthie Shamash. We are principally a legal aid firm with a substantial commercial aspect. I have been in the legal aid business for a very long time: more decades than I care to remember. The problem we have now is that we are operating under a graduated-fee system and a fixed-fee system. Under a fixed-fee system, you can find yourself doing an awful lot more work, and you are stuck. Just before this debate started, I spoke to one of the partners, who said that you can get down, sometimes, as low as £10 an hour. The average rate, and the fixed rate, is about £60 an hour in the magistrates’ court. It is a bit higher in the Crown Court. It was mentioned that, being a lawyer, you sometimes make advocate because you want a bit more money. In this case, I would certainly welcome this amendment.

One of the other points that has been touched on is recruitment. Recruitment of young lawyers to do crime is incredibly difficult. I speak from personal experience. I hope it does not reflect on my firm, but we have had adverts out for a very long time for young criminal lawyers. You are competing with the salaries that you can earn in the City: over £100,000 for a newly qualified lawyer. We cannot even begin to think about paying that sort of rate. It is very difficult, because somebody who comes to do this work has to be politically, with a small ‘p’, very committed to the work they are doing. It is extremely difficult to find the right sort of person to do that. Not least of which, these days, most students who have gone through the education process have ended up with enormous debts. Many noble Lords will be aware of this, having grandchildren or whoever who are at university ending up with considerable debts to be paid at the end of their training. So this is incredibly serious.

The noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas, asked: what are we doing with this? We are going to find ourselves very short of young criminal lawyers. We can see that ourselves. What is going to happen then? Coming back to the debate we had earlier about the number of people waiting to come to trial in a magistrates’ court, sometimes, even at the current time, the wait is two years. In the Crown Court, we have cases that are waiting to be heard in three years’ time. It is complete madness. What is going to happen? I am genuinely very concerned at the situation that we are now confronted with.

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Excerpts
Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB)
- Hansard - -

It is always a great pleasure to follow the noble and learned Lord, Lord Garnier, which I seem to do quite often. It is also a great pleasure to welcome the noble Lord, Lord Stace, and to congratulate him on his maiden speech. I note that he sat down almost exactly on eight minutes, which is a very good augur for the future. Because it is my first opportunity to do so, I should also like to welcome the Minister to the House, and particularly to the Government Front Bench. He may recall that some 20 years ago or so, when I was head of the CPS, he was one of our non-executive directors and, I may say, one of our very best. He will also recall that in those days we both had somewhat darker hair, although, rather annoyingly, he seems to have retained more of his.

This is my first opportunity to welcome the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson of Liverpool, whom I am delighted to see in his place. I am sure that his contributions to the House will be erudite and penetrating, although that does not guarantee that we will always agree.

It is important to acknowledge that we are dealing with the consequences of a funding crisis. That is too often forgotten. Governments in recent years have made the choice not to invest in criminal justice. The direct result has been the backlogs that we now see. The Justice Minister in the other place claimed recently in the media that even if there was not a funding crisis and the backlogs that we are confronting, the Government would proceed with these reforms anyway as a matter of principle. I found her unpersuasive on that point. We are dealing with the results of a funding crisis.

My own service, the CPS, in the not-so-distant past lost some 30% of its budget and some 30% of its front-line prosecutors. Imagine if the National Health Service lost 30% of its front-line doctors. Courts went dark and barristers, because of the collapse in legal aid, left the criminal Bar in droves. That is the situation that we are now confronting. Covid did not help, but successive Governments have used it as a shield for problems which pre-existed it.

Others noble Lords have dealt with matters of principle. I accept that people can have fair trials in front of judges without juries. That is obvious. All over the world, people have fair trials in front of judges. In our commercial courts, people have fair trials in front of judges. However, I want to address the Minister on a more practical issue: will the magistrates’ courts be able to cope with the massive influx of work which this Bill will direct towards them?

With the greatest respect to the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, there were some things about his report that I disagreed with. We debated these disagreements publicly on a podcast. I took the view of the Institute for Government that the reforms that he was proposing would save so little time in the Crown Court that they were not worth the number of jury trials that would be lost as a result. However, his report had one singular merit—it had many merits—that I want to refer to now: that most of the cases removed from juries under his proposals would be presided over instead by a Crown Court judge and two magistrates. The Government’s new proposals, resiling from his report, were trailed in the press as the Government saving jury trial. The new Prime Minister, during his by-election campaign, expressed his great attraction for jury trial and rather implied that the Leveson report would be dead as a result of his affection for it, but that has not happened. The Bill before the House does not succeed in creating any diminution in the right to jury trial. That may be necessary for all the reasons which noble Lords have expressed.

However, I seriously question whether the magistrates’ court, in its current condition, is in a fit state, even with the additions of magistrates which have been described, even with the additions of new district judges that have been described, could deal with this influx of work. At the moment, trials that are conducted in magistrates’ courts are of very minor matters, rarely lasting longer than a day. That will change. Magistrates will keep within their jurisdiction cases which will last for two, three, four or perhaps five days. It is very easy for a lay magistrate to get a day a month off work to do their duty in the magistrates’ court or perhaps even two days a month, but persuading an employer that they should have three or four days—which might stretch into five or six days because the trial takes longer than expected—is a very different kettle of fish.

Journalism is not always terribly accurate, but I found this piece of journalism quite persuasive. A couple of months ago, maybe a little longer, the Times sent a couple of journalists down to a magistrates’ court in the south-east of England. They found a situation of absolute chaos. There were not enough magistrates, barristers not turning up, prisoners not being delivered and witnesses not turning up. If the magistrates are now to deal with two, three, four or five day-long cases, with more serious cases, with more powers of sentencing, we will need many more magistrates, many more district judges, probably more buildings and certainly a more efficient means of delivering prisoners to the courts.

I am not in principle opposed to courts making allocation decisions. In most of the fair trial world, it is not the defendant who decides where he or she should be tried. The noble and learned Lord, Lord Keen, will correct me if I am wrong that in Scotland it is largely the prosecutor who makes that decision. I am not against that. However, I am opposed to a situation which gives courts the right to decide allocation but pays no account to the resources of the courts in question. I urge the Minister to tell the House what modelling has been done to convince the Government that the magistrates’ courts can take on this level of work and how much money will be necessary to enable them to do so. How many more lay magistrates will we need and how many more district judges?

I have never understood why we do not allow defendants to elect trial before judge alone if that is what they wish. I understand that the Government feel that such a proposal would be inconsistent with their new idea that allocation should be a matter for the judges, but if defendants want to be tried by judges, they should be allowed to make that decision. I urge the Government to reconsider their position on that.

Independent Sentencing Review

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Excerpts
Monday 2nd June 2025

(1 year, 5 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Timpson Portrait Lord Timpson (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank my noble friend for his comments. It has been the biggest privilege of my life to be given this role, and to be in your Lordships’ House to debate these crucial reforms to sentencing. I have been involved in and around the sector for most of my working life, and I have seen too many great ideas get ignored, too many wither on the vine and too many go unfunded.

I counted up the number of Prison Ministers I had met before being handed the keys to what was once their office, and it was 14, over just 20 years. I am not sure whether that happened because they enjoyed the role so much that they wanted to move on to another one or because it was too challenging and they wanted to find an easier role elsewhere, but, for me, this is the job that I have come in to do, and I am absolutely delighted that David Gauke and the panel have come up with the ideas that they have.

My noble friend is 100% right about the Probation Service. That is where the heavy lifting is done, and it is at the heart of the system. If you do not get probation funded and operating properly, the rest does not work either. I have met so many amazing probation staff who know exactly what they need to do but feel that they have not been supported enough over the years and that they spend too much time on administration and not enough time face to face with offenders, helping them turn their lives around—and that is the job that they signed up to do.

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I very strongly agree with what the Minister has just said, and I declare an interest in that a close relative of mine works in the Probation Service. It is demoralised, underfunded and depressed, and that will have to change urgently, although, of course, getting probation officers into positions of experience takes time.

I strongly welcome this report and its findings. Does the Minister agree that of all the statistics bandied around on the topic of reoffending, perhaps the most striking is that no less than 39.3% of inmates reoffend within 12 months of their release from custody? That is the point at which the intensive provision part of the three-stage system will kick in. The period when those prisoners who are most at risk of reoffending are being engaged with by the Probation Service and by rehabilitation services will be key to this working, and if that is not got right, the reform will not be got right. As the Minister says, the Probation Service is central to this. Is he confident that he is going to be able to secure sufficient funds to create the sort of transformation that will be required for this scheme to work?

Lord Timpson Portrait Lord Timpson (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am learning how this business works, and when you go to the Treasury, you ask for what you want and then, in our case, we are happy with what we need to do the job. The £700 million is significant and will make a difference, but on top of that, we need to recruit more probation staff, which we are doing. We need to train them really well, and we are doing a review into training. We also need to support them, because the noble Lord is right: 39% of people reoffending is far too high and means more victims as well.

One of the things I learned is that employment makes a huge difference to people when they leave prison. One of the things I tried to do was to interview people when they were in prison, so they started working for me the next day. When I started employment advisory boards, 14% of prisoners had a job after six months. With the work of so many local business leaders and the third sector, that figure is now well over 30%. Those people in a job are far less likely to reoffend.

Community Sentences (Justice and Home Affairs Committee Report)

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Excerpts
Friday 26th July 2024

(2 years, 3 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I hope your Lordships will bear with me as I speak during the gap. I am aware that such contributions are meant to be kept short, so I will speak relatively briefly. I do not need to mention my interest, because it has already been referred to by the noble Baroness, Lady Ludford.

I congratulate the committee on its report, which is absolutely excellent: it is rigorous and well-argued, and a very good piece of work. For my part, I agree with its conclusions and recommendations. I thought the Ministry of Justice’s response was careful and constructive, and also a very good piece of work. That said, I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Hamwee, that the Government ought now to treat this as a springboard, rather than the final word, and to build on that response, because there is progress that can be made.

I will make a couple of points. I was delighted when, on Wednesday—I cannot remember whether it was during questions on the Lord Chancellor’s Statement or during the King’s Speech debate—the Minister went out of his way to remark upon the great attachment to public service of those working within the probation service. I was delighted, because my experience running the CPS taught me that there is nothing more destructive to the morale of a workforce than to be constantly criticised and abused—in the press and, sometimes, even by members of the Government, as I am afraid we have seen in the past. This drains enthusiasm and demotivates; it sucks the lifeblood out of a workforce.

I was interested to hear what the Minister had to say in his remarkable maiden speech about his own business and the way he treats his employees. I hope the Government will take a similar approach. Of course, when things go wrong, they have to be investigated and put right, but it seems that we hear only when things wrong; we do not hear about the countless occasions when the men and women working in our public services get things right.

There are other pressures; it is not simply media and political pressure. As others have made clear, the probation service is badly understaffed and underfunded. There are too many relatively junior probation officers taking on cases which should be reserved for more senior, experienced people, who do not exist in the service. This will take a long time to put right. Recruiting 1,000 new probation officers is better than nothing, but they will be trainee probation officers, at the bottom. Programmes to try to tempt back into service more senior figures who have left in recent years will also be important.

If it will become the aim of this Government, as I very much hope it will, to try to reduce our prison population, the obvious place for them to start will be at the lower end, with those serving shorter sentences who have the highest reoffending rates—over 50% for adults released from serving sentences of 12 months or under. However, if these individuals are released without some form of supervision, the policy will soon discredit itself, and the Government could even be forced into a U-turn. An absolute corollary of reducing the prison population is to boost probation and rehabilitation services. The former cannot happen successfully without the latter.

We are told that there is not enough money, and that may be the case, but we could save some money from the £600,000 it takes to build each new prison cell, put less people in prison, and spend some of that money perhaps on intensive treatment, probation officers and other rehabilitation services. We have the balance of expenditure wrong.

I was very interested in the remarks made by the noble Lord, Lord McNally, during the King’s Speech debate on Wednesday. He is a distinguished former leader of the Liberal Democrats, and I think we can all agree—I am sure Liberal Democrats would—that he is a wise old bird. He made the point that it is important in this debate to keep lines of communication open with the top of the Government.

Baroness Blake of Leeds Portrait Baroness Blake of Leeds (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Could I ask that the noble Lord makes his comments short, and brings them to a conclusion, please?

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB)
- Hansard - -

I will come to a conclusion now.

I was simply going to say that I think that is absolutely right. I knew the new Prime Minister for 25 years at the Bar, first as a practitioner and thereafter when he succeeded me as Director of Public Prosecutions. I think his instincts would tend towards supporting generally the conclusions of this report. If that is right, those inclinations, combined with the Minister’s well-known desire to boost rehabilitation, could lead, at last, to some real reform in this area.

King’s Speech

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Excerpts
Wednesday 8th November 2023

(3 years ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I first got to know Lord Judge well when I was a pretty raw and inexperienced DPP and he became president of the Queen’s Bench Division and head of criminal justice in the Court of Appeal. He was kind, wise and, where necessary, sympathetically firm. These were wonderful qualities in a judge, a Lord Convenor and a friend. I also congratulate the noble and learned Lord, Lord Burnett of Maldon, on his maiden speech. I am sure that his contributions to your Lordships’ House will be important and necessary in the years ahead.

From time to time, both major parties have played their part in an arms race in criminal sentencing. They sometimes seem to want to outbid each other in sentencing policy, no doubt in the belief that this is worth votes. They may, of course, be right about that, but it is surely the role of Governments and Oppositions to sometimes lead and not simply follow. This is particularly true on questions of public policy, where the public mood may not always coincide with what is best. This is an aspect of representative, rather than delegative, democracy.

Everyone involved in British penal policy knows that incarceration is horrendously expensive, that much of the prison estate is crumbling through lack of investment, that inspectors’ reports on prison conditions are frequently a national embarrassment, and, perhaps worst of all, that recidivism rates are appalling and not improving. The figures no doubt reflect, in part, the inadequate provision of rehabilitative schemes. The Government are prepared to grow the prison population by increasing sentences, reducing parole and restricting remission, but they are not prepared to pay for a sufficient increase in prison places to accommodate these policies, for the necessary improvements to the prison estate or for proper rehabilitation to minimise reoffending. In the end, all of this hurts the public.

Perhaps recognising this failure in joined-up policy-making, the Government’s 2021 spending review promised 20,000 new prison places. But by June of this year, only 5,200 of these places had materialised and, according to the Ministry of Justice, we will have just 8,200 by May 2025. The full 20,000 will not be on stream until 2030—if we are lucky. One project has apparently been delayed by the discovery of a badger sett.

In the face of this, our prison population reached over 86,000 in February this year, the highest in western Europe. It is projected to rise to over 94,000 by March 2025, and we are told that it could reach over 108,000 by 2027. As Sir Bob O’Neill, the respected Conservative chair of the Commons Justice Committee, has said, you cannot keep trying to squeeze a quart into a pint pot.

The result of this dispiriting cycle of poor public policy is disgraceful prison conditions almost designed to perpetuate criminal behaviour, ad hoc early release schemes, frankly embarrassing threats to decant British prisoners to jails abroad, and, perhaps most undignified of all, judges having to delay sentencing hearings so that convicted people on bail will not have to be sent to over-capacity prisons just yet.

It should not be beyond the capacity of the British state to design a penal policy that tends towards rehabilitation, that does not rely on emergency release schemes, that does not force us to pay other countries to house our convicts, and that allows judges to get on with the business of dispensing timely justice.

I strongly welcome the brave and sensible approach the Secretary of State has taken to less serious offending and his proposal to reduce—I hope drastically—the number of people sent to prison on short sentences that allow no time for rehabilitation and for which rates of recidivism are so high. However, I am concerned about proposals to abolish remission altogether for certain categories of serious crime, for two reasons. First, remission works as an essential form of behaviour control, particularly in crowded, understaffed prisons. This policy will make the already difficult task of prison staff harder and more dangerous still. Secondly, there is no doubt that this dam, once breached, will breach again. I predict that, if the Government pursue this, the categories of offence with no or reduced remission will grow and the prison population will ramp up.

Finally, what is proposed on whole-life sentences is a very significant change that will greatly increase the number of prisoners serving whole-life terms in our prisons. Can the Minster tell us whether the Government have calculated by how many, or what the impact on prisoner management might be?

It is no insult to the victims of crime to acknowledge that there is a hierarchy of evil in criminal conduct and that whole life has always been reserved for the very worst crimes. The murderer of Zara Aleena, whose sentencing may have played some part in this proposal, committed a terrible crime, and her bereaved family have behaved with extraordinary dignity ever since. In the end, the Court of Appeal decided that the killer deserved a minimum sentence of 33 years but, as the Lady Chief Justice pointed out, that does not mean he was getting a sentence of 33 years. His sentence was life. It simply meant that he was being told that he must serve at least 33 years before he would even be considered for parole. Thirty-three years is a severe penalty, yet the reality is likely to be much harsher.

It is widely recognised by commentators of all political persuasions—indeed, it has become a commonplace observation—that some of these criminal justice proposals in the gracious Speech amount to an attempt by the Government to create political space between themselves and the Opposition in advance of next year’s general election. That is a depressing way for the Government to steward criminal justice.

Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Excerpts
Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood Portrait Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood (CB)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I too support this proposal. The objectives set out in each of the paragraphs (a) to (h) of proposed subsection (2) of the amendment are plainly and urgently needed. It should not be necessary to establish a royal commission to focus on, pursue and achieve these objectives, but plainly it is necessary. These deficiencies have been identified, recognised and discussed for years but, as for getting anywhere in terms of achievement—on the contrary.

The main parties on both sides of the House, not least this Government, seem ever more intent on winning the law and order vote. Sentences are being increased; minimum and mandatory terms are being imposed. We now need the impetus, the force, of no less than a royal commission to start to recognise the intense problems of our whole penal system and to start to set the matter right.

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB)
- Hansard - -

My Lords, I do not regard the United Kingdom’s place at the top of the incarceration league table for western European countries as a badge of honour. It seems to me that this fact in itself calls for a broad strategic view of how sentencing is working in this country and why it is that we send so many more people to prison than other countries do.

One of the issues seems to be that criminal justice, particularly sentencing, has become a political football. A sort of auction has been going on between the main political parties over the last 20 years or so to discover who can present themselves as the toughest on this issue. I do not mean to minimise the effect of crime on victims or on society as a whole, but short sentences in particular are surely counterproductive. The best way to school a young man in crime and anti-social behaviour is to send him to prison for three or six months.

It seems to me that one of the great possible achievements of a royal commission would be to take some of the political sting out of this issue and to inject some rationality and even some science into it. I strongly support the amendment.

Lord Bach Portrait Lord Bach (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, may I ask the Minister a question? A few years ago, when I was a police and crime commissioner, it came across our desk a lot that it was government policy to have a royal commission on the criminal justice system. What has happened to that proposal? Is it still there? Is it still the Government’s hope to do that? If it was, I would be very much in support of it. If it is not, I very much support the amendment that the noble Lord, Lord Marks, has moved.

Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Excerpts
Lord Judge Portrait Lord Judge (CB)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I find myself in a puzzle. The Government of the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, and the noble and learned Lord, Lord Falconer, who introduced this form of sentence, have indicated that they would not have introduced it if they had known how it would work. A different Government, the coalition Government, of which the present Government formed the majority, saw the iniquities of it and Parliament got rid of it. Therefore, we now have a strange system. We have people in custody under the old system and people with the same record, the same problems, the same issues arising, who are not subject to the same sentences as each other. That seems rather strange, but in terms of an Act of Parliament, it is an utterly illogical situation for the Government now not to at least address the consequences of the sentence having been abolished in the 2012 Act.

Quite rightly, that was not made retrospective. I see that retrospectivity must be avoided, but we have been going on with the sentence that has been abolished for eight or nine years now. We all know that something must be done. I am not making a personal comment about the Minister, but everybody knows that it must be done, including Ministers in the Home Office and the Ministry of Justice. We must do something about it, in fairness and logically.

I added my name in support of the amendment tabled by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Brown, but all these amendments are asking one simple question: “You must do something, so will you now tell us what it is?” It is no good us being in a situation where “Something must be done” when “What is going to be done?” is the real question.

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB)
- Hansard - -

My Lords, I hope that the Minister can acknowledge that this is one of those comparatively rare occasions when noble Lords from all parties and none and from across the House have come together in the face of overwhelming evidence that a great public policy, in this case a great criminal justice policy, has gone disastrously wrong. It is beyond argument that IPPs have resulted in periods of incarceration out of any reasonable proportion to the gravity of the original crimes for which they were imposed. That is wrong. It is beyond any reasonable argument that these sentences are beyond any proportion to the risk that continues to be represented by any of the offenders to the public. That is wrong. There is the strongest evidence before the Government that IPPs are observably responsible for persistent and continuing injustice. The noble Lord, Lord Hunt, spoke very movingly about the reality of those injustices for those who are suffering under them.

I declare an interest as president of the Howard League and in doing so repeat what a number of noble Lords have said about the contribution made by Frances Crook. She has been a monumental figure in criminal justice, which is better today for her work than it would have been without it. The Government now have an opportunity to make a startling improvement to our criminal justice arrangements by the simple expedience of doing away with IPPs in their entirety; I agree with the noble and learned Lord, Lord Garnier, in this respect. The evidence could not be clearer. I support all these amendments and urge the Government now, in the face of this overwhelming case, to act.

Lord Pannick Portrait Lord Pannick (CB)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I hope that when the Minister responds to this debate, he can put away the departmental brief and respond to two simple questions. The first is whether he accepts that the present system is unacceptable. The second, which the noble and learned Lord, Lord Judge, posed, is: what will the Government do about it? This is not a new problem. The Government have had years to think about the options and to consider what to do. The noble Lord is already a very distinguished Minister of Justice. Can he say what the Government will now do to address a manifest injustice?

Domestic Abuse Bill

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Excerpts
Committee stage & Committee: 5th sitting (Hansard) & Committee: 5th sitting (Hansard): House of Lords
Monday 8th February 2021

(5 years, 9 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Domestic Abuse Bill 2019-21 View all Domestic Abuse Bill 2019-21 Debates Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts Amendment Paper: HL Bill 124-VI(Rev) Revised sixth marshalled list for Committee - (8 Feb 2021)
Lord Lucas Portrait Lord Lucas (Con) [V]
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I add my name to those saying that this is a change we should make, and now. I would like to be sure, which I am not at the moment, that the wording will cover an image which does not actually exist but is merely asserted to exist. On some of these occasions, a recording will have been made or said to have been made without the victim’s knowledge, but she may well believe that the allegation is true because it is a believable one. Under those circumstances, it should be clear that this offence is activated. I would also like to understand better how one can consent to a threat. If it is a threat, what does consent look like? What would it take for someone to consent to a threat? How would that be phrased; how would it work? Is “publish and be damned” consent? If not, what would be?

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (CB) [V]
- Hansard - -

My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Morgan, for putting down this amendment, which I strongly support.

One way to judge the gravity of a crime is to assess the anguish it brings to its victims. Usually, this emotional suffering comes as a by-product of, say, physical harm or financial loss. However, sometimes the creation of anguish is deliberate, the whole point of the crime, and a source of great satisfaction to the criminal. It is perhaps no surprise that our courts have reserved special condemnation for those responsible for this sort of behaviour. In 2015, amid mounting evidence of a growing problem, the Government decided to tackle the ugly phenomenon of so-called revenge porn: the sadistic online dissemination without consent of sexually explicit photos and videos, usually of young women, and usually by disgruntled former boyfriends. Ministers recognised that this behaviour is particularly nasty because it targets the most private and personal aspects of life, exploiting intimacy to create ridicule, contempt and public shame. Indeed, each of these emotions is precisely what is intended by the perpetrator, particularly the public shaming. This conduct was thus made a crime that could lead straight to prison.

However, it is now clear that the present law does not go far enough, for what about threats to share intimate images? As your Lordships have been told, at present, these attract no criminal sanction at all, although the evidence shows that significant numbers of women and girls face this menacing behaviour.

Much has been said in this debate about the survey carried out by Refuge, the country’s largest provider of domestic abuse services. That is not surprising when the results of this survey appear to show that as many as one in seven young women in England and Wales have faced these threats.

These figures portray a world of anxiety and dread. Because most of these threats come from current or former partners, they also speak of deliberate schemes of domination and control that we should acknowledge for what they are: straightforward examples of domestic abuse. Like all crimes in this category, they gift a gratifying sense of power to the abuser, who is intent on using this power to signal the victim’s utter lack of worth.

Amendment 162 provides the opportunity to change the law to criminalise this behaviour, granting thousands of women and girls access to justice and protection—the first duty of the law. At present the Government prefer to push this issue off into the future, awaiting a Law Commission review into all forms of image-based abuse. But for all the reasons set out by the noble Baroness, Lady Morgan, people subjected right now to this behaviour should not have to wait. I hope the Government will accept what is widely acknowledged: that this is a gap in the law and the Government’s duty is to plug it without delay.

Lord Alderdice Portrait The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Lord Alderdice) (LD)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The noble Baroness, Lady Fox of Buckley, has withdrawn, so I call the noble Lord, Lord Russell of Liverpool.

Criminal Justice and Courts Bill

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Excerpts
Monday 21st July 2014

(12 years, 3 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Baroness Scotland of Asthal Portrait Baroness Scotland of Asthal
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I can assure the Committee that this has been a sober debate on the issues and that it is clear that there is no unanimity of view on any Bench. I believe that the House of Lords is demonstrating its independence and doing what it does best, which is to argue and disagree, and then, it is hoped, to come to a consensus.

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (LD)
- Hansard - -

My Lords, amen to that. Like the last several speakers, I had not intended to intervene in the debate—this could go on all night, I suppose—but I want to make two points. First, it was my experience, not only as chief prosecutor but also over very many years of practising criminal law, that sentences of between four and six months are not just pointless, as many speakers have indicated, they are positively damaging. Young people who are sent into young offender institutions for four to six months do not come out with nothing, they come out with worse than nothing. I have always thought that it was a preposterous policy to send young people into incarceration for such periods, and yet that is precisely what this Bill mandates, and in that sense it will do serious damage.

The second issue is mandatory sentencing. We have a good example of a jurisdiction that has gone down the route of mandatory sentencing: the United States of America, which has well known federal sentencing guidelines. The prison population in the United States of America stands presently at 3 million.

Lord Kennedy of Southwark Portrait Lord Kennedy of Southwark (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, when I make contributions to these debates, I am always conscious of a sense of nervousness because so many distinguished noble and learned Lords have contributed to the debate. I am not a lawyer: I come to the debate as a lay person. On these Benches, we are unable to support the noble Lord, Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames, although we share his concerns about the effects of stop and search. We must have procedures in place to discourage the carrying and use of weapons. I am sure that the noble Lord, Lord Faulks, will confirm when he responds to the debate that he believes, as I do, that the Bill should allow for judicial discretion.

It is important that the Government deal with the issues that lead people, particularly young people, to commit these offences. I agree with the comments of the noble Lord, Lord Paddick, who talked about getting into schools. It is not enough to lock up young people who commit offences without dealing with the causes that lead them to do so. What will be provided to deal with the problems? Many noble Lords made that point about what actually happens to people who are in prison for short sentences.

I agree with the comments of the noble Lord, Lord Deben, about how this provision got into the Bill in the first place in the Commons. It came in very late. That is regrettable. I also agree with the comments of the noble Lord, Lord Blair.

As my title indicates, I grew up in Southwark, on a council estate. I was very happy there. I do some work with a local charity working with kids on council estates all over the borough and the neighbouring borough of Lambeth. It seeks to get kids to play football together. You can hardly fight as you play football together. I recently spent some time with the charity. I was shocked and depressed by how much depended on the estate you lived on, so that when you walked home if you walked a certain route, you would have real problems. I met one young lad who lived on the Wyndham estate, right next to my primary school. The estate is 50 yards from the borough of Lambeth, but he told me that he never walked across into the borough because he was scared. He would never cross the road. I could not believe that—it is an absolutely shocking situation. We have to deal with those problems.

The charity organised a World Cup in Kennington Park, and it got different council estates and different nationalities playing football together—meeting up and playing football together rather than fighting each other in the evenings. That was fantastic. This chap does all this work, with virtually no funding from the local authority, from the Government or from anybody. It is fantastic. These are the sort of things that we would all agree need our full support.

My response to the noble Lord, Lord Paddick, is that I agree with the noble and learned Lord, Lord Mackay—this is about a deterrent which will keep people out of prison. We are not actually sending people to prison. I also agree with many of the comments of my noble friend Lady Howells and the noble Baroness, Lady Berridge. However, I am confused about the Liberal Democrat position. I mentioned in my speech at Second Reading that in the LASPO Act, the Liberal Democrats supported mandatory sentences for carrying a threatening or offensive weapon. The question was raised recently in the Commons and an amendment agreed without a Division. There is now an offence of carrying an offensive weapon in public with a mandatory maximum sentence of four years. I find that a bit odd in terms of what comments I have heard and taken note of from the Liberal Democrat Benches.

Assisted Dying Bill [HL]

Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Excerpts
Friday 18th July 2014

(12 years, 3 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Macdonald of River Glaven Portrait Lord Macdonald of River Glaven (LD)
- Hansard - -

My Lords, if this Bill passes into law it will, I believe, herald a fundamental and irreversible shift in the attitude of the state to the deliberate application of death. If it takes place, I am sure that this shift will in time, and perhaps not long into the future, bring further changes in our approach to death by human hand. Many people will support this present shift and some will support the shifts to come. For my part, I do not.

When I was the Director of Public Prosecutions between 2003 and 2008, scores of these cases came across my desk. They are always considered by the DPP personally, not by a lawyer in his office. I did not in a single circumstance authorise a prosecution against anyone who, through compassion, had helped a son, a daughter, a husband, a mother or a friend to die. It was as long ago as 1949 that Hartley Shawcross, the great Nuremberg prosecutor and Attorney-General in the post-war Attlee Government, reminded the House of Commons that it has never been the law of England that in every case where there is sufficient evidence for a prosecution, that prosecution must be brought. That is because in this jurisdiction we have always understood that inflexibility and justice rarely go hand in hand. There is nothing new in that; it has been part of our system of justice over the years. So it is that prosecutors have, and always have had, a discretion. Where there is sufficient evidence, they have always asked themselves, “Would it be in the public interest to prosecute this case?”.

The position we have arrived at in this country is this: a broad prohibition of law to deter those who might take action through venal motives—and such people do exist. It would be foolish to assume that everyone counselling a suicide acts from pure motives or that venality is always absent. However, coupled with that prohibition of law is a clearly defined discretion to protect those who face an impossible choice and who act from motives that are beyond reproach. Under the system as it presently exists, they do not and they will not face prosecution. To those who respond by saying, “But these people face the uncertainty of investigation before they are relieved of the threat of prosecution”, my response is that surely it is unthinkable, even under the scheme being proposed by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Falconer, that there should be no inquiry following an assisted death, if only to determine that a detailed and prescriptive law such as the one he is proposing has been complied with and not broken. There will always be an inquiry and there should always be an inquiry. If I am wrong about that, and if in fact we are being invited to enter a world in which the deliberate infliction of death is protected from inquiry, I believe that we should decline that invitation, as I do.