Question

To ask the Scottish Government how much has been spent by each public inquiry in each of the last 10 years, broken down by the type of cost incurred, including the salary of the chairperson.

Answered by Forbes, Kate - Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Gaelic

Public inquiries are independent of Government, and each inquiry is responsible for publishing its own financial information. This can be found on the website of each respective Inquiry. For inquiries established under the Inquiries Act 2005 there is a statutory duty on the Chair to “act with regard to the need to avoid any unnecessary cost” (s.17(3))

The Edinburgh Trams Inquiry reported in September 2023. The costs for the Tram Inquiry from 2015 until it reported are £13,007,617.02. The salary paid to Lord Hardie as Chair of the Inquiry from 2015 until conclusion was £1,128,468. Information relating to the total costs of the Inquiry and the Chair’s fees were previously made publicly available in the media in articles published in June 2023 and September 2023, albeit the information previously published covered a different time frame.

In respect of the Sheku Bayoh Inquiry, overall costs are published on the Inquiry website Inquiry costs | Sheku Bayoh Inquiry From the date that this Inquiry was established to the date your question was lodged, the Scottish Government has provided the Sheku Bayoh Inquiry with £711,680 to pay Lord Bracadale for his role as Chair to the Sheku Bayoh Inquiry.

In respect of the Scottish Hospitals Inquiry, overall costs are published on the Inquiry website Inquiry Costs | Hospitals Inquiry. From the point when the Scottish Hospitals Inquiry was established in 2020 to the date on which your question was lodged the Scottish Government has provided the Scottish Hospitals Inquiry with £727,040 to pay Lord Brodie for his role as Chair to the Scottish Hospitals Inquiry.

In respect of the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry, overall costs are published on the Inquiry website Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry | Cost of the Inquiry. From the point when the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry was established in May 2015 the cost of salaries for the Chairs is £2,216,613 (initially Susan O’Brian then subsequently Lady Smith). Lady Smith’s appointment began on 1 August 2016. From her appointment until March 2022 the sum was paid to the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service as Lady Smith was a sitting judge and President of the Tribunals in Scotland as well as her role as Chair of the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry.

With regard to the Scottish Covid-19 Inquiry, overall costs are regularly published on the Inquiry website Inquiry costs | Scottish COVID-19 Inquiry. The Chair of the Scottish Covid-19 Inquiry is Lord Brailsford. As a sitting judge, Lord Brailsford is remunerated by the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service. The terms of the Chair’s appointment have been published on the Inquiry website. Any questions on judicial appointment terms are for the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service to answer but salary scales can be found at https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/judicial-salaries-and-fees-2023-to-2024

In respect of the Eljamel Inquiry, overall costs will be published on the Inquiry website Inquiry costs | The Eljamel Inquiry. In relation to the Eljamel Inquiry, the salary of Lord Weir for his role as the Chair for the year 2024-25 was £196,199.