Scotland Bill

Debate between Lord Field of Birkenhead and Russell Brown

Tuesday 21st June 2011 Commons Chamber

[Mr Field]

I said, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I was anxious to speak briefly so that other people might be able to contribute—after waiting many hours—so I will not go down that route. However, the hon. Gentleman knows that his is not the answer.

[Mr Russell Brown]

I want to put the record straight for my right hon. Friend and his constituents. He talks about free prescriptions in Scotland, which we now have, but I hasten to remind him that there was a period of two to three years when people south of the border with cancer-related problems got their medication free, while people in Scotland were paying for their prescriptions. This is about priorities. The Labour Government rightly made that decision, and it was just a shame that the Scottish Government did not follow suit at the time.

[Mr Field]

Much as I admire my hon. Friend, I obviously should not have given way, because he is distracting me from the argument that I wish to make, which is a simple one. I am not convinced of the basis for those differences, and neither are many of my constituents. I have affection for the way our different nations have been grouped into the United Kingdom, but I am anxious, because unless we start to face these questions and answer them soon a general sourness will enter into English politics, and we will not be able to judge where that sourness will lead us.