Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill

Debate between Lord Carlile of Berriew and Baroness Cumberlege

Monday 17th June 2013 Lords Chamber

[Baroness Cumberlege]

The noble Lord, Lord Alli, got it absolutely right. I will draw my remarks to a conclusion.

[Lord Carlile of Berriew]

I apologise for intervening at this late stage of my noble friend’s speech, but I would like to be clear about the consequences of what she is saying. Does she propose that a registrar who is opposed on conscientious grounds to divorce should have the right to refuse to marry people who are entering into a second marriage after divorce?

[Baroness Cumberlege]

No, my Lords, I am not going into divorce. I am trying to keep my proposed amendment quite narrow. I am trying to find a middle way, a way that allows registrars to have a conscientious objection because they are not bit parts in this exercise—they are intrinsic to it. I think they should have that right, just as doctors, teachers and everybody else that I have mentioned do. I also understand, having been in local government and knowing how registrars work, the issue of having to work out the workforce that is required to carry out these functions. I am saying that if a registrar is trying to exercise a conscience clause—the clause that we are here trying to give that person—but there is a shortage of registrars within that area, I am afraid that he or she would be compelled to do it.