Scotland Bill

Debate between Earl of Caithness and Lord Davidson of Glen Clova

Thursday 15th March 2012 Lords Chamber

[Lord Davidson of Glen Clova]

It is not for me to answer for the Government. Doubtless that will be done in due course but, accepting the kind invitation for the moment, it is plainly desirable to have a coherent starting point. Simply to say, “This can now be devolved and the Scottish Government can set off on their own way, without any regard to what is happening in the rest of the UK”, might be unhelpful not only to the rest of the UK but to Scotland.

I apologise if I did not pick up on his enthusiasm for advancing this in order to reduce the power to create new taxes. I understand his concern about the extent of that power. However, it might be interesting to note that the Holyrood Scotland Bill Committee has accepted that once the future of this tax has been decided, it should be considered for devolution then. Therefore, it would appear that while the noble Lord, Lord Forsyth, is in advance of the Scottish Government in their demands for ever greater powers, at least in Holyrood there has been an indication that they are prepared to wait.

[The Earl of Caithness]

My Lords, I did not find the argument of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Davidson, at all convincing. Does it mean that the UK Government are now not allowed to look at any taxes which they are proposing to transfer to Scotland? If they are looking at air duty and saying, “No, you cannot give it to Scotland as the UK Government are looking at it”, and given that there is a Budget coming up, presumably, to follow the noble and learned Lord’s argument, we should not devolve anything to Scotland.

[Lord Davidson of Glen Clova]

My Lords, it is always a danger to generalise from the particular. In this instance, one sees that we on this side are content that the tax be devolved in due course—but where the people in Scotland, as expressed through their Bill Committee, seem to see virtue in waiting, we would agree with them.