(5 days, 9 hours ago)
Lords ChamberMy Lords, again, if the Committee will forgive me, I will speak only briefly. I start by expressing my support for the remarks made by the noble Baroness, Lady Hayman, in speaking to her Amendment 52. It seems impossible to argue that the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care should be exempt from a duty to be mindful of the climate change agenda in everything they do, especially as we remember that the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care presides over an organisation with a very large carbon footprint. It was very much with that in view that Section 9 of the Health and Care Act 2022 included duties on NHS England to have regard, in the exercise of its functions, to the Climate Change Act 2008. Therefore, the noble Baroness was entirely right that the duties that apply currently to NHS England in this area should now logically apply to the Secretary of State.
Having said that, I would be surprised if the Minister did not respond by saying that the first part of Amendment 52 is unnecessary, for the very dull reason that Section 15 of the Climate Change Act 2008 already places a duty on “the Secretary of State”, in exercising his or her functions, to have regard to
“the need for UK domestic action on climate change”;
the section spells out what that means in practice. It has long been drummed into me that an Act of Parliament conferring duties on “the Secretary of State” should be read in law as applying to any Secretary of State. That is a very legalistic point, and I do not think that it constitutes a sufficient reason for the Minister to resist this amendment, for all the reasons set out so well by the noble Lord, Lord Crisp.
Personally, I feel the need for something declaratory and specific in this area. The duty to issue detailed guidance seems a very definite omission from the Bill. As we heard the Minister say in response to the previous group of amendments, climate change is becoming a highly relevant factor for ICBs and trusts in the planning of service delivery. As the noble Baroness, Lady Boycott, was right to emphasise, it is equally relevant in the public health context and to the design of buildings, including hospitals. With all that in mind, I hope that the Minister will feel able to give the noble Baroness’s amendment a positive response.
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who took part in the debate on this important group of amendments. I will address Amendments 52 and 248 together.
I turn first to Amendment 52, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Hayman. The Government remain committed to tackling climate change and ensuring that the NHS continues to play its part. I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Crisp, that this is an overarching priority. However, we do not believe that this amendment is necessary. I am indeed going to say that the climate change target and environmental targets referred to in the amendment already apply to the Secretary of State through the Climate Change Act and the Environment Act. The 10-year health plan was clear that we will continue to support the NHS’s climate ambitions. The reforms in this Bill do not remove or weaken that commitment.
The amendment also provides for guidance on the discharge of climate duties. However, the Bill already enables the Secretary of State to issue such guidance to integrated care boards, alongside transferring NHS England’s existing guidance powers for NHS trusts and foundation trusts to the Secretary of State. Importantly, integrated care boards, NHS trusts and foundation trusts will retain their existing statutory climate duties. We will continue to support the aims of the NHS’s climate ambitions in a way that improves delivery of care, returns savings to front-line services and drives wider economic growth. I say to the noble Baronesses, Lady Coffey and Lady Bennett, that I look forward to debating in full the use of single-use plastics in the NHS in the group of amendments on medicines and medical devices beginning with Amendment 111, but I will not pre-empt a fulsome discussion of that by delving into that content here, so we can all look forward to that.
I turn to Amendment 248, in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Boycott. NHS trusts and foundation trusts have to consider the need to adapt to the current and predicted impacts of climate change. All trusts and foundation trusts are already required to have green plans in place. In reply to the noble Baroness’s point about how we will ensure that this happens, following the abolition of NHS England, the Secretary of State will issue guidance to support the system in discharging their duties, building on the existing Green Plan Guidance published by NHS England. There are statutory guidance-making powers in the NHS Act 2006 for ICBs, trusts and foundation trusts, under which the Secretary of State expects to issue guidance to support that system in discharging its duties.
As many noble Lords raised, including the noble Baroness, Lady Hayman, we know that the impacts of climate change are already being felt across the NHS, including disruption from heat in particular, flooding and other types of extreme weather. That is why the 10-year capital plan committed to renew that focus on climate resilience. We have strengthened adaptation planning with green plans to prepare for severe weather events and improve climate resilience of local sites and services, and plan to conduct an adverse weather emergency response exercise in every NHS region by 2030, so strengthening that whole system preparedness for extreme heat through UKHSA-led planning, co-ordinated alerts and mandatory local response arrangements across the NHS.
All trusts are required to have adverse weather plans to ensure service continuity during major events, such as heatwaves. Beyond planning for acute incidents, trusts also undertake climate change risk assessments to identify and reduce overheating risks and their potential impacts. There is already, therefore, a clear framework for trusts to plan and respond to climate risks. I humbly suggest that the Government do not have their head in the sand but that our focus should be on delivering against these existing duties and plans. The 10-year health plan also committed to supporting the NHS’s existing net-zero targets and climate objectives as set out in Delivering a “Net Zero” National Health Service, published in 2020. I am sure noble Lords are aware that, since the publication of that strategy, NHS carbon footprint emissions have indeed fallen by 17%.
To address the point raised by the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, I have covered some of the local duties points. The CQC guidance will remain, but I will write in full laying that out. On the point from the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, about how this will be reported to Parliament, information on annual NHS emissions will continue to be published in the DHSC’s annual report and accounts, which are also laid before Parliament annually. That will ensure that Parliament continues to receive that regular information on the NHS’s progress towards those environmental objectives. I hope that this reassures noble Lords that the Government recognise the importance and, as many noble Lords have raised, ongoing salience of this issue.