(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords Chamber
Baroness Gill
To ask His Majesty’s Government what discussions they have had with Ofcom regarding the impact of elected politician-led current affairs programming on public trust in broadcast news impartiality.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (Baroness Mackenzie of Sherwood) (Lab)
My Lords, Ministers and officials have regular discussions with Ofcom. Under Ofcom’s broadcasting code, no politician may be used as a newsreader, interviewer or reporter on any news programme unless, exceptionally, it is editorially justified.
Baroness Gill (Lab)
My Lords, I thank my noble friend for that. But last month a Demos report revealed that the UK is a total outlier in Europe for allowing politicians to host news and current affairs programmes. Out of 37 countries surveyed, 35 had absolutely no recent examples of this. The UK stands virtually alone, yet Ofcom’s enforcement remains incredibly lax, exploiting a thin distinction between news and current affairs to avoid taking action. Given that the most advanced democracies strictly ban these practices, what actions does my noble friend the Minister plan to take to close these loopholes and protect the credibility of our democracy?
Baroness Mackenzie of Sherwood (Lab)
I thank my noble friend. As she said, the Demos report sets out that approaches taken on this issue vary across our European neighbours. The Government remain concerned about politicians presenting programmes that could reasonably be interpreted as news or current affairs. There is a clear rationale to strengthen the rules in the UK, and we are considering options to tackle this problem. We will set out our decision as soon as we are able to.
Baroness Bonham-Carter of Yarnbury (LD)
My Lords, surveys have repeatedly shown that broadcast news is by far the most trusted news source in the UK. Does the Minister agree that, as the noble Baroness, Lady Gill, said, the arbitrary distinction between news programmes on the one hand and current affairs programmes on the other, which does not exist in the 2003 Communications Act and which Parliament did not intend, undermines the trust in broadcast news at the very moment that disinformation is thriving in the online world?
Baroness Mackenzie of Sherwood (Lab)
As the noble Baroness says, the distinction was not clearly made in the 2003 Communications Act, which, in my former life as a special adviser, I played a role in—for which, apologies. The world has changed since then, and that is why our media Green Paper set out a pathway for us to work on this issue. I know that the noble Lord, Lord Hall, raised a series of very sound points, which he is very well qualified to make from his former life, about rethinking the distinctions between news and current affairs. I hope that we may be able to report further actions and thoughts on that as soon as possible.
My Lords, on 15 September this year, Nigel Farage, while presenting on GB News, said of the £72 million donations to Reform UK, “Actually, the lumps of money that Reform have now been given gets us back to some—just some—sense of parity with the other parties”. In my view, this is a political statement in breach of impartiality rules. Would the Minister agree?
Baroness Mackenzie of Sherwood (Lab)
Reform TV, as a user-to-user service on YouTube, is regulated at the moment under the Online Safety Act, and that does not cover the issues that the noble Viscount raised. Through the media Green Paper, we are considering how the TV regulatory framework will need to adapt to continue to protect audiences, support both growth and innovation, and maintain standards in future.
My Lords, it is debatable what in broadcast news affects public trust. When I asked the Minister on 19 October whether her department had requested and gained access to the BBC’s most sophisticated public trust data, which shows how different demographic groups trust the BBC, the Minister did not know the answer and promised to get back to me. As I have yet to hear from her, I will repeat that question and, in doing so, remind her how important this detailed information—not aggregate data—is to the current charter renewal discussions, and the Government’s misplaced proposal to designate some news as trusted and give it prominence on social media.
Baroness Mackenzie of Sherwood (Lab)
I will start by apologising to the noble Baroness. I have not yet written to her with the information, but I will absolutely ensure that I do that before the end of this week. I completely agree that this sort of data is vital for us to understand the current situation. Of course, as we all know, this landscape is changing very fast in terms of what sections of the population acquire their news from what sources, which is increasingly from online and social media sources as well as from trusted broadcasters, and therefore the ways in which we can best protect all our citizens and safeguard the future of trusted news for the next 20 years or so.
My Lords, is it not the case that our democracy is at risk from allowing the right wing to control most of the media and abuse the rules by having a right-wing politician interviewed by a right-wing interviewer? Do we not need to do something about this? Ofcom has proven in the past that it cannot take the action needed. Why do we not change Ofcom to make sure it is an effective organisation?
Baroness Mackenzie of Sherwood (Lab)
My thanks for that comprehensive question. We need to remind ourselves that for public service broadcasters there are very clear rules about impartiality and very clear rules that prevent the erosion of the distinction between political opinion and the reporting of news. As mentioned earlier, these rules do not cover other forms of news and channels where people access news. Ofcom is an independent regulator. It is independent of the Government and is, of course, answerable to Parliament and reports regularly to it. The Ofcom model has been widely copied around the world and I think is one that we should stick to. We have regular meetings with Ofcom where we discuss the ways in which it can respond to issues in a timely and effective manner.
My Lords, the government local news fund has awarded more than £266,000 to Bylines Network, the sister organisation of the left-wing Byline Times news network. The two organisations share founders and directors, and have a documented history of financial and operational co-operation. Can the Minister confirm whether these relationships were examined before the grant was awarded and what safeguards ensure that taxpayers’ money cannot directly or indirectly subsidise the wider political journalistic operation?
Baroness Mackenzie of Sherwood (Lab)
The noble Lord raises a very important point, which I am afraid is not in my briefing notes. I will have to come back to him as soon as I can.
My Lords, the Demos study referred to by the noble Baroness, Lady Gill, showed that regular presenting by serving politicians of not just current affairs programmes but entertainment programmes as well is not tolerated across the rest of Europe. Should we not introduce legislation to stop this? As the noble Baroness said, it is a failure in our democracy.
Baroness Mackenzie of Sherwood (Lab)
It is entirely reasonable to look at the blurring of the lines between news and current affairs, and how they are being blurred further, for example with chat shows. We need to beware of sweeping up the whole of entertainment and all of those genres. I am sure that many of us would be sad if “Strictly Come Dancing” no longer had access to working or former politicians—only my point of view, obviously. In all seriousness, as was said, the Green Paper has set out some initial thinking in this area and we intend to do further work to get in line with our European partners and ensure the safety of news and impartiality across the genres, as appropriate.