(1 day, 17 hours ago)
Commons ChamberA Ten Minute Rule Bill is a First Reading of a Private Members Bill, but with the sponsor permitted to make a ten minute speech outlining the reasons for the proposed legislation.
There is little chance of the Bill proceeding further unless there is unanimous consent for the Bill or the Government elects to support the Bill directly.
For more information see: Ten Minute Bills
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
I beg to move,
That leave be given to bring in a Bill to require the use of closed-circuit television (CCTV) in nurseries; to make provision about the retention, storage, disclosure and review of such CCTV recordings; to make provision about minimum standards and auditing requirements for digital devices used to access CCTV recordings in such settings; and for connected purposes.
This year, Vincent Chan was arrested and put in prison for 18 years for sexually abusing babies and young children while he was working in a nursery in my constituency. Police seized his devices and the devices of Bright Horizons nursery where he worked, and found tens of thousands of illicit, inappropriate sexual images. Some 1,500 of those images fell into category A, which is the most extreme sexual imagery.
I have spent the last year working with affected parents whose children went to the nursery. They have said to me that sexual abuse is a parent’s worst nightmare in any situation, but it is a double blow when people have put their children in a safe haven and gone to work, thinking that they have created a home away from home where the children will be looked after, protected and nurtured and then return home and be happy. The second thing I learned from dealing with those parents is that the parents who know that their children were abused have to face a life of trauma, counselling and therapy, but there are also parents who have absolutely no idea what actually happened to their children. In a way, those parents feel worse, because the truth is that they may never find out what happened to their children. The only evidence that is available to account for Vincent Chan’s crimes is the images he took himself—the ones he recorded, kept and used for his purposes. There is no independent visual evidence from which we can find out what he did and the extent of his crimes.
I want to tell the story of one of the parents, who I will call Jessica—some of the parents are in the Gallery today as I speak. Jessica’s young daughter had Vincent Chan as a key worker. She told me that the police discovered numerous images on his devices of her very young daughter making inappropriate, sexually suggestive gestures with her fingers and lips. In the background of some of those photos, another staff member can be seen. Jessica feels that if CCTV had been in place, the whole situation would have been different. For a start, if Vincent Chan was taking pictures in a busy, crowded nursery where there was CCTV, that might have worked as a deterrent and made him think, “Should I be doing this? I could be caught.”
The wider point is that Vincent Chan had been at the nursery for seven years. Perhaps the staff member who was in the background of those photos was new, and did not feel confident enough to report her suspicions. It is difficult to report that your colleague is doing something that you think is suspicious, because you may be challenged and asked for evidence. If that staff member had had the confidence of knowing that CCTV would provide independent visual evidence of her suspicions, she might have been more inclined to go to the manager and say, “I think something is wrong here.” CCTV is not just about providing evidence after a crime has been committed, leading to a conviction. It can also be used as a deterrent—a tool to stop people doing something because they are fearful of being caught—and as a way of giving other staff members confidence that if they are worried, and if they go and complain, they can be backed up by the CCTV.
The children who Vincent Chan targeted were pre-school children. They could not speak up for themselves, so they could not explain or articulate exactly what was happening; the only thing that some of the three and four-year-olds could say was that they were frightened to go to nursery, or were scared of certain people. One of the children did so, and when they complained—when they said they were scared of going to nursery and named their key worker—a complaint was made about Vincent Chan. The nursery undertook an investigation, cleared him and allowed him to return to work, three years before he was arrested. If there had been CCTV, perhaps the nursery could have looked at it when that investigation took place and found out about the extent of his crimes, and he could have been stopped from abusing children for three further years.
I am not naive—I do not think CCTV is the silver bullet that is going to fix all the problems we have with safeguarding in our nurseries. There is a lot more that needs to be done: we need to have a proper flare system, through which people can report any concerns about nursery workers; we have to make sure that Ofsted looks at devices before it carries out its inspections and makes an assessment; and we need to have a proper ratio of adults to children. There is a crisis in our nurseries at the moment—some 20,000 safeguarding incidents have been reported in English nurseries over the past five years. Something has to be done, and I do not think CCTV will solve everything, but I think it would be a very good first step in making sure that we safeguard the most vulnerable.
I know that the House is used to hearing sensitive material, but the two cases I am about to outline are very distressing. The first is that of Roksana Lecka, who was convicted of abusing 21 babies at Riverside nursery in Twickenham, where she was working. Metropolitan police detectives went through CCTV from that nursery that showed her pinching and scratching children aged between 18 months and two years under their clothes on their arms, legs and stomachs, sometimes dozens of times a day. On one occasion she was seen pushing babies head-first on to cots, and on another she was seen covering the mouth of a toddler who was crying. In this case, CCTV was essential to the prosecution.
Another horrific case happened in Bristol, where Nathan Bennett’s crimes came to light when concerns were raised by his colleagues and by parents. In that case, a nursery manager looked at the footage from the 18 CCTV cameras in the nursery and realised the extent of his crimes. This is exactly what safeguarding should be like: there should be a designated nursery worker who can look at the CCTV footage and the evidence if a concern is ever raised, enabling a conviction if necessary.
The problem we have with nurseries in our country is that some nursery chains use CCTV, but there is no consistent national standard. I call on the Government to introduce a model similar to the Australian system, under which nurseries can apply for a grant from the Government. The Australian childcare CCTV trial is part of a federal system to enhance safety in the childcare sector, partially in response to high-profile allegations of misconduct. Some $189 million is now available for small and medium-sized operators, enabling them to purchase and install CCTV cameras for childcare centres, with $11.5 million targeted at not-for-profit childcare centres. We would expect large chains such as Bright Horizons to pay for themselves.
I believe that the Government should consider amending Information Commissioner’s Office guidance to require nurseries to operate safeguarding CCTV in all rooms, with secure local monitoring, strict access controls, audited retention and carefully limited remote access. Where remote access is permitted, it could be via authenticated, child-specific log-ins and governed by clear safeguarding and data protection protocols. The Government could provide clear guidance on data retention, including on how long footage should be kept for, when it should be deleted, and how it should be preserved automatically if a safeguarding concern is raised. Digital devices used around children should be technically restricted so that they can upload only to approved internal systems and applications, with no external data transmission other than tightly controlled authorised workflows.
We cannot afford to have gaps in our safeguarding when it comes to the most vulnerable people in our country, in the constituencies where we live. We have to safeguard the future of nurseries, and where children cannot speak for themselves, we have to be a country that listens to them and keeps them safe when they are in nursery.
I congratulate the hon. Member for Hampstead and Highgate (Tulip Siddiq) on bringing forward the ten-minute rule Bill and raising this very important subject. I am sure we are all four-square behind her and her constituents in relation to the suffering they have had to go through at the hands of a rogue in a rogue nursery.
What I am going to say this afternoon is based on the fact that the world is full of people with good intentions, but the road to hell is paved with good intentions. The nursery system in this country is already a lot more expensive for parents than any other in the European Union. When it comes to the number of children or babies in individual nurseries, we have much higher supervision ratios, and I am concerned that in bringing forward this Bill, the hon. Lady is essentially bypassing the regulator we have put in place. Ofsted—the Office for Standards in Education, Children’s Services and Skills—is already obliged to look at the standards that apply in our nurseries. I would be interested to know whether, and to what extent, they have looked into the cases that the hon. Lady has raised today. However, why are we saying that we will second-guess the judgment of Ofsted? If it wanted to—if it thought it appropriate—it could require nurseries to introduce CCTV universally.
I would like to just mention the costs. My understanding is that there are some 13,842 day nurseries in England alone. That large number of nurseries, and all the people who work in them and all the children who benefit from them, is the context into which we need to put the ghastly cases that the hon. Member for Hampstead and Highgate has cited. If we were to force all those nurseries to introduce CCTV, it is estimated that the additional cost would be about £50 million in capital costs, and if I understood the hon. Lady correctly, she was implying that most of that £50 million should come from an additional grant from the Government. What I am saying is that we should surely rely upon Ofsted to make a judgment as to whether an additional £50 million of investment in CCTV is required in our nurseries, or whether it wishes to make some other adjustments to ensure that the rogues who have got into the system cannot continue to operate. The safeguarding measures are a big bit of regulation, because not a lot of people can go into a nursery and work there unless they have passed the relevant tests and had the relevant checks carried out as to their reliability and character.
My concern, as on so many occasions in this House, is that we keep thinking that the answer to every problem is to have more legislation and more regulation. What is often the best answer, however, is for the regulators who have already been given responsibility for this area to get down to work and make their own recommendations balancing the costs and benefits. That way, we can continue to have good nursery education in this country, while hopefully reducing the costs, which are higher than in the European Union. For some parents, sending a child to nursery costs 25% of their income. In France, for example, that cost is only about 5% or 10%. [Interruption.] Instead of putting more financial burdens upon nurseries, why do we not just—[Interruption.] Will you stop shouting at me?
Order. Please be seated. Let us be respectful. Every Member has the right to be heard. Sir Christopher, you are on the clock, and there are not many minutes left.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I am tempted to take up the whole of the time just to satisfy the hon. Member for Sutton and Cheam (Luke Taylor) that I am in charge at the moment, but I am not going to do that.
Instead, I will bring my remarks to a close by saying that we should have some proportionality. I fear that Members cannot say, without being interrupted, “Hang on a minute, why do we want to do more regulation and to impose more legislation when the regulators have failed?” We should be trying to ensure that the regulators are fit for purpose. When the hon. Member for Hampstead and Highgate brings forward her Bill—I will not press it to a Division, because I think it is the right of every Member to be able to bring forward a Bill, and I hope that it gets debated in due course—I will seek to make amendments to reflect my point of view.
Question put (Standing Order No. 23) and agreed to.
Ordered,
That Tulip Siddiq, Dame Priti Patel, Nigel Huddleston, Sir Alec Shelbrooke, Bob Blackman, Munira Wilson, Mr Tom Morrison, Liz Saville Roberts, Olivia Bailey, Janet Daby and Matt Western present the Bill.
Tulip Siddiq accordingly presented the Bill.
Bill read the First time; to be read a Second time on Friday 15 January 2027, and to be printed (Bill 184).