To match an exact phrase, use quotation marks around the search term. eg. "Parliamentary Estate". Use "OR" or "AND" as link words to form more complex queries.


Keep yourself up-to-date with the latest developments by exploring our subscription options to receive notifications direct to your inbox

Speech in Commons Chamber - Mon 06 Jan 2025
Police Funding: Cambridgeshire

Speech Link

View all Sam Carling (Lab - North West Cambridgeshire) contributions to the debate on: Police Funding: Cambridgeshire

Written Question
Breast Cancer: Screening
Friday 20th December 2024

Asked by: Sam Carling (Labour - North West Cambridgeshire)

Question to the Department of Health and Social Care:

To ask the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, if his Department will make an assessment of the potential merits of lowering the minimum age of mammograms for breast cancer checks.

Answered by Andrew Gwynne - Parliamentary Under-Secretary (Department of Health and Social Care)

We currently do not screen those younger than 50 years old for breast cancer due to the lower risk of women under this age developing breast cancer, and the fact that women below 50 years old tend to have denser breast tissue, which reduces the ability of getting an accurate mammogram. It may also increase the risk of overtreatment and distress for women who do not have breast cancer, but who would be subject to invasive and painful medical treatments and diagnostic tests.

United Kingdom guidelines recommend that women with a moderate or high risk of breast cancer, because of their family history, should start having screening mammograms every year in their forties. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence guidance on the management of people with a family history of breast cancer was introduced in 2004, and has changed over time. The current version of this guidance is available at the following link:

https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg164

There is a large trial, Age Extension, which is exploring whether an additional screen before 50 years old would meet the UK National Screening Committee’s criteria. Results are expected in 2026.


Division Vote (Commons)
17 Dec 2024 - National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill - View Vote Context
Sam Carling (Lab) voted Aye - in line with the party majority and in line with the House
One of 345 Labour Aye votes vs 0 Labour No votes
Vote Tally: Ayes - 354 Noes - 202
Division Vote (Commons)
17 Dec 2024 - National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill - View Vote Context
Sam Carling (Lab) voted No - in line with the party majority and in line with the House
One of 346 Labour No votes vs 0 Labour Aye votes
Vote Tally: Ayes - 195 Noes - 353
Division Vote (Commons)
17 Dec 2024 - National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill - View Vote Context
Sam Carling (Lab) voted No - in line with the party majority and in line with the House
One of 345 Labour No votes vs 0 Labour Aye votes
Vote Tally: Ayes - 196 Noes - 352
Division Vote (Commons)
17 Dec 2024 - National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill - View Vote Context
Sam Carling (Lab) voted No - in line with the party majority and in line with the House
One of 347 Labour No votes vs 0 Labour Aye votes
Vote Tally: Ayes - 206 Noes - 353
Division Vote (Commons)
17 Dec 2024 - National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill - View Vote Context
Sam Carling (Lab) voted No - in line with the party majority and in line with the House
One of 346 Labour No votes vs 0 Labour Aye votes
Vote Tally: Ayes - 100 Noes - 351
Division Vote (Commons)
11 Dec 2024 - Finance Bill - View Vote Context
Sam Carling (Lab) voted Aye - in line with the party majority and in line with the House
One of 311 Labour Aye votes vs 0 Labour No votes
Vote Tally: Ayes - 332 Noes - 170
Division Vote (Commons)
11 Dec 2024 - Trade - View Vote Context
Sam Carling (Lab) voted Aye - in line with the party majority and in line with the House
One of 298 Labour Aye votes vs 0 Labour No votes
Vote Tally: Ayes - 375 Noes - 9
Division Vote (Commons)
11 Dec 2024 - Finance Bill - View Vote Context
Sam Carling (Lab) voted Aye - in line with the party majority and in line with the House
One of 313 Labour Aye votes vs 0 Labour No votes
Vote Tally: Ayes - 338 Noes - 170