(1 day, 10 hours ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mrs Barker. I congratulate the hon. Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) on securing this important debate. She is a doughty champion for her constituents, and her opening remarks were a powerful articulation of entirely legitimate concerns about the role of water companies in planning for new residential development. I also thank the other hon. Members who participated in the debate; I welcome the valuable insights that they shared from their constituencies.
I want to make it clear at the outset that I note and appreciate fully the concerns that exist across the House in respect of the delivery of water supply, drainage and waste water infrastructure. I recognise how strongly hon. Members feel about this matter. Water scarcity is a genuine and growing constraint, and not for one second, in anything I say, am I conveying the Government’s view that the status quo is acceptable. There is a real problem here, and it is complex, but in the time available I want to detail the steps that the Government have already taken to address the issue and to reassure hon. Members, if I can, that we are acutely aware of the need to do more, and in particular to ensure—to address the point well made by the hon. Member for Bicester and Woodstock (Calum Miller)—much closer alignment between planning for development and planning for necessary water and waste water infrastructure.
I want to touch briefly on the national planning policy framework, because it is very clear that sustainable development should be pursued, both through the preparation and implementation of local development plans and through the application of policies in the framework in decision making. In short, national policy is unambiguous that new housing must be accompanied by appropriate provision for water supply, drainage, waste water, water management and flood risk infrastructure.
However, I must make it clear that the focus of planning policies and decisions should be whether proposed development is an acceptable use of land, rather than matters that are subject to control under other regulatory regimes. In short, planning decisions should assume that those regimes operate effectively. That reflects a well-established position in law: the courts have consistently held that it is not the role of the planning system to duplicate controls that are the statutory responsibility of other bodies, nor should decision makers substitute their own judgment on matters for which other regulators hold relevant expertise and responsibility.
If the hon. Member will allow me to make a linked point, he can then come back to me if he wants to.
Infrastructure constraints can be a material consideration; I think the hon. Member for Chichester said that they could not be, but they can. Where there is clear evidence that a regulatory regime is not operating effectively in a particular area, decision makers may need to depart from the general assumption. However, such departures must be based on substantive evidence, not a precautionary approach. In other words, the planning system should not become a proxy regulator for the water industry.
If the hon. Member for Witney (Charlie Maynard) still wants to intervene, I am happy to give way.
Charlie Maynard
I thank the Minister. Does he accept that up and down the country, developments are being approved and brought forward despite everybody knowing that no water treatment capacity will be built out and, in many cases, that the capacity is already failing? The carte blanche answer that the law will cover it is not working. We are in a completely failing predicament.
I will come on to some points of detail that I hope will address that. I will say that where appropriate, planning conditions and obligations can play a role. They were dismissed by hon. Members earlier, but they are legally enforceable, provided that the relevant legal and policy tests are satisfied. Let me make a few more points; the hon. Gentleman is more than welcome to intervene again, if there is time.
The hon. Member for Chichester asked me about schedule 3 to the Flood and Water Management Act 2010, which provides a statutory framework for sustainable drainage systems. The Government’s position is that 16 years have passed since the introduction of the Act. We need to consider the most efficient and effective way of securing the objectives of part 3, and our considered view is that they are best achieved through national policy, which we have strengthened. The national planning policy framework now makes clear that for developments of all sizes, sustainable drainage techniques should be used where a development could have drainage impacts, and appropriate long-term management arrangements should be in place. The framework, as now constituted, will mean that sustainable drainage technologies are taken up far more widely in new development, but the Government will continue to monitor whether more needs to be done.
On the central point of the debate, in August, in parallel to the publication of the new NPPF, the Government published our response to the consultation on reforms to the statutory consultee system. We were clear that the system is not operating effectively: we were told as much not only by housebuilders but by local planning authorities across the country. The Government response confirmed that we will maintain the moratorium on new statutory consultees in the planning application process, subject to periodic review.
While the Government considered carefully the case for giving water companies statutory consultee status, we are clear that statutory consultations should be focused where a legal duty is necessary and adds value. In our view, creating blanket additional statutory requirements can introduce duplication, regulatory burden and delay, without necessarily ensuring that the underlying infrastructure is planned or delivered any earlier. Indeed, I would go further, as I did in a debate on 12 March 2025, when I touched on many of the same issues discussed today. I would argue that making water companies statutory consultees not only is not a panacea, as several hon. Members have accepted, but would risk allowing them to argue against the delivery of new homes rather than focus on their responsibility to ensure that the appropriate infrastructure is in place at the outset.
Of course—this is important—water companies not having statutory consultee status does not prevent them from submitting their views on individual applications. There seemed to be some confusion from the Liberal Democrats that being a statutory consultee offers a veto over planning decisions—it does not. Statutory consultees are allowed to input material considerations, which water companies can already do on individual planning applications. Any interested party can make representations. Water companies can work proactively with councils to identify developments of interest, and where particular water issues arise, local planning authorities can consult them directly.