NHS

Debate between Margot James and Luciana Berger

Wednesday 5th February 2014 Commons Chamber

[Luciana Berger]

I just do not know what to say to that because it is so ridiculous. There was an increase of 16,000 in the last three years of the Labour Government, which has rocketed to 633,000 in the first three years of this Government. The gap in those figures is tremendous. The GP contract happened in 2004. When have we seen crises in A and E? Not under the Labour Government, but under this Government—the Tory-Liberal Democrat Government.

What else has happened under this Government? We have seen the Health Secretary handing back £2.2 billion of underspend to the Treasury, 2,300 managers receiving six-figure pay outs and £1.4 billion siphoned off to pay for redundancies. My right hon. Friend the Member for Leigh also raise the issue of the amount of money NHS trusts are now having to spend on expensive legal fees as a result of competition, introduced through the Health and Social Care Act. That goes to show that when it comes to our NHS, this Government know the cost of everything but the value of nothing.

As the hon. Member for Stafford (Jeremy Lefroy) said, our elderly population is growing, but half a million fewer older people are receiving support compared to 10 years ago. That means more older people going to A and E because they cannot receive the care they need at home, and more older people stuck in hospital beds because there is no safe place to discharge them to.

[Margot James]

Will the hon. Lady give way?

[Luciana Berger]

I am not giving way because I have only three minutes left.

As my right hon. Friend the Member for Leigh said earlier, the CQC recently reported that in the last year, more than half a million pensioners were admitted as an emergency to hospital with potentially avoidable conditions. There is another reason for that: it is now harder, not easier, to get a GP appointment under this Government. The Royal College of General Practitioners says that it will soon become the norm for people to wait a week or longer to see their GP. Just this week, I was contacted by a constituent whose partner was suffering from chest pains. They contacted the GP but could not get an appointment for eight days.

This is what patients are having to endure right across the country, and it is being made even harder by the cost of living crisis hitting families all over Britain. People are having to eat less, and less healthily, and more than half a million people are being forced to turn to food banks. As my hon. Friend the Member for Worsley and Eccles South described so poignantly, carers are having to make the choice between heating and eating. GPs are now asking patients when they last had a meal. It is no coincidence that, as food bank use has exploded, so have cases of malnutrition. There has been a 42% increase in malnutrition cases, and in 2012-13 more than 5,000 people were thus diagnosed in English hospitals. I share the view of my hon. Friend the Member for Stretford and Urmston that that is a disgrace in 21st-century Britain.

Doctors are now treating diseases we thought had all but disappeared. It is not just scurvy; rickets and vitamin deficiency are also on the rise. The Government have already given us the longest fall in living standards since the 1870s; we now have the Victorian diseases to match. They should be ashamed of every single case of these 19th-century diseases returning to 21st-century Britain.

That is not all. With energy bills up by £300 and more children living in fuel poverty, is it any wonder that episodes of hypothermia have jumped by 40% in the past three years? We have seen a 29% increase in the number of excess winter deaths—31,000 deaths that by definition were entirely preventable—while new figures this week show a dramatic increase in the number of older people being admitted to A and E for cold-related illnesses. Furthermore, there have been 145,000 more cases of over-75s being treated in hospital for respiratory or circulatory diseases, compared with 2009-10.

Ministers cannot resolve the crisis in our NHS. They know what is happening and that their policies are stoking the crisis, but they will not admit it. Only Labour can preserve, protect and progress our NHS. Our approach focuses on the patient, and it champions integration and collaboration, not competition, fragmentation and profit. We want a public, integrated NHS free at the point of use, and a whole-person approach that combines physical, mental and social care and helps to take the pressure off A and E. That is the principle behind our motion today, and I urge Members on both sides of the House to support it.