All 1 Lord Desai contributions to the Extension of Franchise (House of Lords) Bill [HL] 2017-19

Read Bill Ministerial Extracts

Fri 19th Jul 2019

Extension of Franchise (House of Lords) Bill [HL] Debate

Full Debate: Read Full Debate
Department: Cabinet Office

Extension of Franchise (House of Lords) Bill [HL]

Lord Desai Excerpts
2nd reading (Hansard): House of Lords
Friday 19th July 2019

(5 years, 5 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Extension of Franchise (House of Lords) Bill [HL] 2017-19 Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Desai Portrait Lord Desai (Lab)
- Hansard - -

My Lords, we are all grateful to the noble Lord for raising a very acute constitutional question. It may surprise many Members of your Lordships’ House to hear that I am very conflicted about it, because I am not at all sure that whatever activity I indulge in in my own constituency or in the country by way of politics necessarily qualifies me to vote in an election. The central fact is that we are an undemocratic House. Having arrived here, we are given the privilege of legislating, and we have to pay a price for that—it is very simple. The fact is that an undemocratic Chamber that is able, in a democracy, to legislate and lay down the law without any reference to the people has to pay a price. I am an economist: if you have a benefit, you pay a price.

The idea that every vote counts is really frightening. If a seat went one way or the other due to the vote of a local grandee, people would be outraged. Part of the Brexit rebellion and so on is that people are asking, “Who are these people laying down the law?” I am sorry but when we came here we gave up certain rights. If you want to vote, the way is open: leave the House and renounce your title. Everybody has that choice. Yes, the Members of this House should be able to vote but only after the House has been reformed and is an elected Chamber.