Inheritance Tax, National Insurance and VAT

Lord Davies of Brixton Excerpts

Monday 27th January 2025 Lords Chamber

[Lord Davies of Brixton (Lab)]

We need to thank the noble Lord, Lord Morrow, for introducing this debate. I admire the passion and clarity of the arguments he presented; unfortunately, I just do not agree. I think the Labour Government’s adjustment—the Motion says removal, but of course it is not being removed; it is being cut back—of APR for inheritance tax, the increase in national insurance contributions and the extension of VAT to private school fees are all steps towards greater economic fairness in funding for public services.

We had a debate on the school fees issue, in which I spoke and I do not wish to repeat what I said there. We are having an apparently endless debate in the Committee on the national insurance contributions Bill, and I will save my remarks on that for that arena. But I will add that the point that the money will be spent on improved public services—providing jobs and buying in services from suppliers—is always ignored by the opponents of the increase in national insurance contributions. Perhaps my noble friend could say something about the positive impact that will have on the economy, as reflected in the figures from the OBR.

I am running out of time, but I will say something about inheritance tax. I do not give advice on inheritance tax, but I do read the financial pages. Clearly, until this whole debate took place, the general view was that inheritance tax was essentially voluntary; you paid it only if you did not arrange your affairs appropriately. Now is not the time to provide advice but, given succession planning and insurance, the problems can be overcome.