Scotland Bill

Debate between David Mowat and Gemma Doyle

Thursday 27th January 2011 Commons Chamber

[David Mowat]

I thank my hon. Friend, but I have two points in response. First, the Government have said that they will not review the formula in the lifetime of this Parliament. Secondly, the outcome allocation that is consequent on what we call the Barnett formula takes into account two things—the spending brought forward and the Barnett consequentials. The first of those is not adjusted for population, and the second is.

Since I have nearly got to the end of my remarks, I will not take any more interventions on this subject, but—

[Gemma Doyle (West Dunbartonshire) (Lab/Co-op)]

rose—

[David Mowat]

Maybe one more.

[Gemma Doyle]

I am very grateful. Is the hon. Gentleman aware that the proposals to which he refers, which he seems to support, could actually lead to a £4.5 billion cut in the amount of money spent on Scotland? Is that what he proposes, and does he want to see it happen?

[David Mowat]

What I propose is that the allocation be done on a needs basis that is fair to the constituents whom I represent as well as to hers.