Energy Market Reform

Baroness Primarolo Excerpts

Wednesday 24th October 2012 Commons Chamber

The House divided: Ayes 223, Noes 297.Division No. 85][3.59 pmAYESAbbott, Ms DianeAbrahams, DebbieAinsworth, rh Mr BobAlexander, HeidiAli, RushanaraAnderson, Mr DavidAshworth, JonathanBailey, Mr AdrianBain, Mr WilliamBanks, GordonBarron, rh Mr KevinBayley, HughBeckett, rh MargaretBegg, Dame AnneBenn, rh HilaryBenton, Mr JoeBerger, LucianaBetts, Mr CliveBlackman-Woods, RobertaBlears, rh HazelBlomfield, PaulBlunkett, rh Mr DavidBradshaw, rh Mr BenBrennan, KevinBrown, LynBrown, rh Mr NicholasBrown, Mr RussellBryant, ChrisBuck, Ms KarenBurden, RichardByrne, rh Mr LiamCampbell, Mr AlanCampbell, Mr RonnieCaton, MartinChapman, JennyClark, KatyClarke, rh Mr TomCoaker, VernonCoffey, AnnConnarty, MichaelCooper, RosieCooper, rh YvetteCrausby, Mr DavidCreagh, MaryCreasy, StellaCruddas, JonCryer, JohnCunningham, AlexCunningham, Mr JimCunningham, Sir TonyCurran, MargaretDanczuk, SimonDavid, WayneDavidson, Mr IanDe Piero, GloriaDenham, rh Mr JohnDobbin, JimDobson, rh FrankDodds, rh Mr NigelDonaldson, rh Mr Jeffrey M.Donohoe, Mr Brian H.Dowd, JimDoyle, GemmaDromey, JackDugher, MichaelDurkan, MarkEagle, Ms AngelaEagle, MariaEfford, CliveElliott, JulieEllman, Mrs LouiseEngel, NataschaEsterson, BillEvans, ChrisFarrelly, PaulField, rh Mr FrankFitzpatrick, JimFlello, RobertFlint, rh CarolineFlynn, PaulFovargue, YvonneFrancis, Dr HywelGardiner, BarryGilmore, SheilaGlass, PatGlindon, Mrs MaryGodsiff, Mr Roger Goggins, rh PaulGoodman, HelenGreatrex, TomGreen, KateGreenwood, LilianGwynne, AndrewHain, rh Mr PeterHamilton, Mr DavidHamilton, FabianHanson, rh Mr DavidHarman, rh Ms HarrietHarris, Mr TomHealey, rh JohnHepburn, Mr StephenHermon, LadyHeyes, DavidHilling, JulieHodge, rh MargaretHodgson, Mrs SharonHoey, KateHosie, StewartHowarth, rh Mr GeorgeHunt, TristramIrranca-Davies, HuwJackson, GlendaJamieson, CathyJarvis, DanJohnson, rh AlanJohnson, DianaJones, GrahamJones, HelenJones, Mr KevanJones, Susan ElanJowell, rh Dame TessaKaufman, rh Sir GeraldKeeley, BarbaraKhan, rh SadiqLammy, rh Mr DavidLavery, IanLazarowicz, MarkLeslie, ChrisLewis, Mr IvanLong, NaomiLove, Mr AndrewLucas, CarolineLucas, IanMacShane, rh Mr DenisMactaggart, FionaMahmood, Mr KhalidMahmood, ShabanaMalhotra, SeemaMann, JohnMarsden, Mr GordonMcCabe, SteveMcCann, Mr MichaelMcCarthy, KerryMcClymont, GreggMcDonagh, SiobhainMcDonnell, Dr AlasdairMcDonnell, JohnMcFadden, rh Mr PatMcGovern, JimMcGuire, rh Mrs AnneMcKechin, AnnMcKenzie, Mr IainMcKinnell, CatherineMeacher, rh Mr MichaelMeale, Sir AlanMearns, IanMiliband, rh DavidMiller, AndrewMitchell, AustinMorrice, Graeme (Livingston)Morris, Grahame M. (Easington)Mudie, Mr GeorgeMunn, MegMurphy, rh Mr JimMurray, IanNandy, LisaNash, PamelaOnwurah, ChiOwen, AlbertPaisley, IanPearce, TeresaPhillipson, BridgetPound, StephenRaynsford, rh Mr NickReed, Mr JamieReeves, RachelReynolds, EmmaRitchie, Ms MargaretRobertson, AngusRobertson, JohnRobinson, Mr GeoffreyRotheram, SteveRoy, LindsayRuane, ChrisSarwar, AnasSeabeck, AlisonShannon, JimSharma, Mr VirendraSheerman, Mr BarrySheridan, JimShuker, GavinSkinner, Mr DennisSlaughter, Mr AndySmith, rh Mr AndrewSmith, AngelaSmith, NickSpellar, rh Mr JohnStringer, GrahamSutcliffe, Mr GerryTami, MarkThomas, Mr GarethThornberry, EmilyTimms, rh StephenTrickett, JonTurner, KarlTwigg, DerekUmunna, Mr ChukaVaz, ValerieWalley, JoanWatts, Mr DaveWeir, Mr MikeWhiteford, Dr EilidhWhitehead, Dr AlanWilliams, HywelWilliamson, ChrisWilson, PhilWilson, SammyWinnick, Mr DavidWinterton, rh Ms RosieWishart, PeteWoodward, rh Mr ShaunWright, DavidWright, Mr IainTellers for the Ayes:Tom Blenkinsop andNic Dakin NOESAdams, NigelAldous, PeterAmess, Mr DavidAndrew, StuartBacon, Mr RichardBaker, SteveBaldry, Sir TonyBaldwin, HarriettBarclay, StephenBarker, rh GregoryBeith, rh Sir AlanBellingham, Mr HenryBeresford, Sir PaulBerry, JakeBingham, AndrewBinley, Mr BrianBirtwistle, GordonBlackman, BobBlunt, Mr CrispinBone, Mr PeterBottomley, Sir PeterBrady, Mr GrahamBrake, rh TomBray, AngieBridgen, AndrewBrine, SteveBrooke, AnnetteBrowne, Mr JeremyBruce, FionaBruce, rh Sir MalcolmBuckland, Mr RobertBurley, Mr AidanBurns, ConorBurns, rh Mr SimonBurrowes, Mr DavidBurt, AlistairBurt, LorelyCairns, AlunCampbell, rh Sir MenziesCarmichael, rh Mr AlistairCarmichael, NeilCarswell, Mr DouglasCash, Mr WilliamChishti, RehmanClappison, Mr JamesClark, rh GregClarke, rh Mr KennethClifton-Brown, GeoffreyCoffey, Dr ThérèseCollins, DamianColvile, OliverCox, Mr GeoffreyCrabb, StephenCrockart, MikeCrouch, TraceyDavey, rh Mr EdwardDavies, GlynDavies, PhilipDavis, rh Mr Davidde Bois, NickDinenage, CarolineDjanogly, Mr JonathanDorrell, rh Mr StephenDorries, NadineDoyle-Price, JackieDrax, RichardDuddridge, JamesDuncan, rh Mr AlanDuncan Smith, rh Mr IainDunne, Mr PhilipEllis, MichaelEllison, JaneEllwood, Mr TobiasElphicke, CharlieEustice, GeorgeEvans, GrahamEvans, JonathanEvennett, Mr DavidFallon, rh MichaelFarron, TimField, MarkFoster, rh Mr DonFox, rh Dr LiamFrancois, rh Mr MarkFreeman, GeorgeFreer, MikeFuller, RichardGale, Sir RogerGarnier, Sir EdwardGarnier, MarkGauke, Mr DavidGeorge, AndrewGibb, Mr NickGilbert, StephenGillan, rh Mrs CherylGlen, JohnGoldsmith, ZacGraham, RichardGrant, Mrs HelenGray, Mr JamesGreen, rh DamianGreening, rh JustineGrieve, rh Mr DominicGriffiths, AndrewGummer, BenHames, DuncanHammond, StephenHands, GregHarper, Mr MarkHarrington, RichardHarris, RebeccaHart, SimonHarvey, Sir NickHaselhurst, rh Sir AlanHayes, Mr JohnHeald, OliverHeath, Mr DavidHemming, JohnHenderson, GordonHerbert, rh NickHinds, DamianHoban, Mr MarkHollingbery, GeorgeHollobone, Mr PhilipHolloway, Mr AdamHopkins, KrisHorwood, MartinHowarth, Sir GeraldHowell, JohnHughes, rh SimonHuhne, rh ChrisHunt, rh Mr JeremyHuppert, Dr JulianHurd, Mr NickJackson, Mr StewartJames, MargotJavid, SajidJenkin, Mr BernardJohnson, GarethJohnson, Joseph Jones, Andrew Jones, rh Mr DavidJones, Mr MarcusKawczynski, DanielKelly, ChrisKennedy, rh Mr CharlesKirby, SimonKnight, rh Mr GregKwarteng, KwasiLaing, Mrs EleanorLancaster, MarkLansley, rh Mr AndrewLatham, PaulineLaws, rh Mr DavidLeadsom, AndreaLee, JessicaLee, Dr PhillipLeech, Mr JohnLefroy, JeremyLeigh, Mr EdwardLeslie, CharlotteLetwin, rh Mr OliverLloyd, StephenLopresti, JackLord, JonathanLoughton, TimLuff, PeterMacleod, MaryMain, Mrs AnneMaude, rh Mr FrancisMaynard, PaulMcCartney, JasonMcCartney, KarlMcIntosh, Miss AnneMcLoughlin, rh Mr PatrickMcPartland, StephenMcVey, EstherMenzies, MarkMiller, rh MariaMills, NigelMilton, AnneMitchell, rh Mr AndrewMoore, rh MichaelMorgan, NickyMorris, Anne MarieMorris, DavidMosley, StephenMowat, DavidMulholland, GregMunt, TessaMurray, SheryllMurrison, Dr AndrewNeill, RobertNewmark, Mr BrooksNewton, SarahNokes, CarolineNorman, JesseNuttall, Mr DavidOfford, Dr MatthewOllerenshaw, EricOpperman, GuyPaice, rh Sir JamesParish, NeilPatel, PritiPaterson, rh Mr OwenPawsey, MarkPenning, MikePenrose, JohnPercy, AndrewPhillips, StephenPickles, rh Mr EricPincher, ChristopherPoulter, Dr DanielPrisk, Mr MarkPritchard, MarkPugh, JohnRaab, Mr DominicRandall, rh Mr JohnRedwood, rh Mr JohnRees-Mogg, JacobReevell, SimonReid, Mr AlanRobathan, rh Mr AndrewRobertson, rh HughRobertson, Mr LaurenceRogerson, DanRudd, AmberRuffley, Mr DavidRussell, Sir BobRutley, DavidSanders, Mr AdrianSandys, LauraScott, Mr LeeSelous, AndrewSharma, AlokShelbrooke, AlecShepherd, Mr RichardSimpson, Mr KeithSkidmore, ChrisSmith, Miss ChloeSmith, HenrySmith, JulianSmith, Sir RobertSoames, rh NicholasSoubry, AnnaSpencer, Mr MarkStevenson, JohnStewart, IainStewart, RoryStreeter, Mr GaryStride, MelStuart, Mr GrahamStunell, rh AndrewSturdy, JulianSwales, IanSwayne, rh Mr DesmondSwinson, JoSwire, rh Mr HugoSyms, Mr RobertTapsell, rh Sir PeterTeather, SarahThurso, JohnTimpson, Mr EdwardTomlinson, JustinTredinnick, DavidTruss, ElizabethTurner, Mr AndrewTyrie, Mr AndrewUppal, PaulVaizey, Mr EdwardVara, Mr ShaileshVickers, MartinWalker, Mr CharlesWalker, Mr RobinWard, Mr DavidWatkinson, AngelaWeatherley, MikeWebb, SteveWharton, JamesWheeler, HeatherWhite, ChrisWhittaker, CraigWhittingdale, Mr JohnWiggin, Bill Willetts, rh Mr David Williams, RogerWilliams, StephenWilliamson, GavinWillott, JennyWilson, Mr RobWollaston, Dr SarahWright, JeremyWright, SimonYeo, Mr TimYoung, rh Sir GeorgeTellers for the Noes:Karen Bradley andMark HunterQuestion accordingly negatived.

[Madam Deputy Speaker (Dawn Primarolo)]

Before we proceed to the next debate, I have to announce the results of the deferred Division on the Question relating to the draft Housing Benefit (Amendment) Regulations 2012. The Ayes were 260 and the Noes were 206, so the Ayes have it.

[The Division list is published at the end of today’s debates.]