"My Lords, it seems to me rather odd that the Government think it so important that we should have a change in magistrates’ appeals to the Crown Court when they are only 0.4%. I am also concerned that individuals in the magistrates’ court are largely not represented. I am further …..." Baroness Butler-Sloss - View Speech
"My Lords, I think your Lordships know that I was President of the Family Division. I also played a very small part in the creation of the Children Act 1989 by being the chairman of the report of the Cleveland child abuse inquiry, some of which got into the Act.
"I have the most enormous sympathy for what the noble Lord is saying, but when the presumption existed, even in the cases of reasonable parents, it was not uppermost in their minds—uppermost in their minds was to win. With any luck, those parents who sensibly do not come to court …..." Baroness Butler-Sloss - View Speech
"My Lords, I have the greatest respect for the noble Baroness, Lady Levitt, but in this she is entirely wrong.
First, the amendment is unnecessary. Why change something that is working perfectly well? That question must be asked. She has not set out what happens at this moment. The noble …..." Baroness Butler-Sloss - View Speech
"It is the Business and Property Division. There was an Order in Council recently that created the Business and Property Division, taking over the Chancery Division and parts of the King’s Bench Division.
But the Criminal Division works perfectly well within the King’s Bench Division because it is the same …..." Baroness Butler-Sloss - View Speech
"My Lords, the Committee should listen with particular care to what the noble Lord, Lord Pannick, just said. It seems to me that, if there are pending contempt proceedings, it would be very unwise of this Committee to support this amendment at this stage...." Baroness Butler-Sloss - View Speech
"My Lords, I put my name to this amendment with some hesitation. I was keen that it should be widely discussed, as it has been today. I declare that I was not only a family judge but, like all other judges, I had to try some crime. However, perhaps more …..." Baroness Butler-Sloss - View Speech
"I am delighted to follow the noble Lord, Lord Foster, and his most interesting speech. This is an excellent debate on crucial issues, and I am so glad that the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, has managed to bring it forward. I also say how glad I am that the noble …..." Baroness Butler-Sloss - View Speech
"My Lords, I thank the right reverend Prelate for his very kind words—totally undeserved but very kind. I very much support this report and its recommendations. As we have a manifesto commitment, it seems to me extremely difficult to go behind it. I am well over the age of 80, …..." Baroness Butler-Sloss - View Speech