To match an exact phrase, use quotation marks around the search term. eg. "Parliamentary Estate". Use "OR" or "AND" as link words to form more complex queries.


Keep yourself up-to-date with the latest developments by exploring our subscription options to receive notifications direct to your inbox

Speech in Public Bill Committees - Thu 26 Mar 2026
Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

"It is absolutely right and proper that we do that. I would like to go a step further: we could probably organise a sit-down with Natalie Elphicke Ross and the team at the Defence Housing Service. It has already been thought through, but they can explain it. If the right …..."
Al Carns - View Speech

View all Al Carns (Lab - Birmingham Selly Oak) contributions to the debate on: Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

Speech in Public Bill Committees - Thu 26 Mar 2026
Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

"New clause 7 would require there to be a feasibility study when establishing a forces housing association, but before I go into the detail, I will reflect on some of the comments made by the right hon. Member.

Recruitment and retention are intrinsically linked, as both the Government and the …..."

Al Carns - View Speech

View all Al Carns (Lab - Birmingham Selly Oak) contributions to the debate on: Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

Speech in Public Bill Committees - Thu 26 Mar 2026
Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

"Perhaps that is why we are not taking it forward now.

Furthermore, the Ministry of Defence heavily subsidises rents. There have been suggestions that the Defence Housing Service could borrow private finance off the balance sheet if it was a housing association rather than a public body. However, expert advice …..."

Al Carns - View Speech

View all Al Carns (Lab - Birmingham Selly Oak) contributions to the debate on: Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

Speech in Public Bill Committees - Thu 26 Mar 2026
Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

"The board of the Defence Housing Service will be accountable to the Secretary of State. I will not go into the detail of the NAD’s bonuses and how they are credited in the Bill, because they are not related.

That renewal will not only benefit the country as a whole …..."

Al Carns - View Speech

View all Al Carns (Lab - Birmingham Selly Oak) contributions to the debate on: Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

Speech in Public Bill Committees - Thu 26 Mar 2026
Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

"On the question of accountability, the board will report directly to the Secretary of State. There will be no filtering and no taint on any information coming up. Therefore, I do not necessarily agree with the premise of the hon. Gentleman’s intervention.

I will address new clause 7 in my …..."

Al Carns - View Speech

View all Al Carns (Lab - Birmingham Selly Oak) contributions to the debate on: Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

Speech in Public Bill Committees - Thu 26 Mar 2026
Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

"I make it clear that we are not talking about amending the Renters’ Rights Act; we are talking about the Armed Forces Bill, but I am happy to take this offline and talk about the nuance between the two if required. We need to be clear that this does not …..."
Al Carns - View Speech

View all Al Carns (Lab - Birmingham Selly Oak) contributions to the debate on: Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

Speech in Public Bill Committees - Thu 26 Mar 2026
Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

"I shall speak first to amendment 2. I thank the hon. Member for his engagement.

The measures in the Bill build on 18 months of work to stop the rot in defence housing and build for the future. We are buying back 36,000 military family houses from Annington and delivering …..."

Al Carns - View Speech

View all Al Carns (Lab - Birmingham Selly Oak) contributions to the debate on: Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

Speech in Public Bill Committees - Thu 26 Mar 2026
Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

"Single living accommodation is often hundreds of rooms—think student accommodation—in barrack blocks behind the wire. Service family accommodation is often on the other side of the wire, out in the local population. Single living accommodation houses individuals rather than families. The whole set-up is completely different—some have cooking facilities and …..."
Al Carns - View Speech

View all Al Carns (Lab - Birmingham Selly Oak) contributions to the debate on: Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

Speech in Public Bill Committees - Thu 26 Mar 2026
Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

"The requirements are different for SLA and family accommodation, but we both want the same thing: the best accommodation, whether for a family or a single person living on base, either separated from their family or single. What I can offer the hon. Member is to engage and talk him …..."
Al Carns - View Speech

View all Al Carns (Lab - Birmingham Selly Oak) contributions to the debate on: Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

Speech in Public Bill Committees - Thu 26 Mar 2026
Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)

"There is some confusion here. The Minister for the Armed Forces does not deal with the housing, the people or the welfare; he deals with the operation and policy output. There is a clear understanding of that. Amendment 16 refers to

“ the Minister of State for the Armed Forces”.

…..."

Al Carns - View Speech

View all Al Carns (Lab - Birmingham Selly Oak) contributions to the debate on: Armed Forces Bill (Third sitting)