House of Lords: Relocation

Debate between Lord True and Lord Lang of Monkton

Tuesday 14th July 2020 Lords Chamber

[Lord True]

My Lords, I recommend courtesy by everybody, Executive or otherwise, in dealing with colleagues and with Parliament.

[Lord Lang of Monkton (Con) [V]]

My Lords, the rumour is a persistent one. Does my noble friend agree that our bicameral parliamentary system strengthens the checks and balances of the Executive in Parliament? How would splitting the system and moving to York this House, in which no Government have a majority, improve those checks and balances? Is it not the case that this would not be decentralisation, as has been mooted in the rumours, but would in reality deliver more centralisation into the hands of the Executive in London?

[Lord True]

My Lords, I agree that practical working considerations are important. I repeat, however, one of the wider considerations here, which is that the Government’s intention, which was very clear in the manifesto, is to find ways to bring the whole process of government closer to the people. I do not believe that Parliament or, indeed, this House should simply reject that concept or the idea that that matter needs to be reflected on. Constructive proposals and discussion of this are always welcome.