Independent Schools: VAT Exemption

Lord Taylor of Holbeach Excerpts

Thursday 5th September 2024 Lords Chamber

[Lord Taylor of Holbeach (Con)]

My Lords, I am delighted to follow the noble Lord, Lord Griffiths. I have always liked his contributions to debate and today is no exception. I particularly wish to thank my noble friend Lord Lexden for proposing this debate, because it is opportune. It is really important that we talk about this issue. The debate shows that education is seen by all of us here as a public good—something that needs investment.

I think the present Government are mistaken in believing that they have a solution in trying to transfer resources from the independent sector to the public sector. That is the wrong way to go about raising money to reinforce education. There are other ways of raising tax not on the subject itself. If it is education today, it could be medical and social care tomorrow—the NHS equally needs investment; its staff equally need pay. I say to noble Peers opposite and the Government that I really think this is the wrong way of going about the problem.

I will talk a little about my personal history. I am a local person: I was born in Holbeach, lived in Holbeach and went to Holbeach infant school, aged four. I loved my school; I always liked being educated and learning things and it was a very satisfying experience. But, unfortunately, when I got to the end of the school and was due to move on to secondary school, aged nine, I was too young to sit the 11+ and there was no secondary modern in Holbeach. Because my parents were state-educated individuals, I was directed to the Holbeach boys’ school, which contained adolescents aged 15. My parents were horrified that I would not be able to cope with this and they sent me away to school.

Some people may say that that is a terrible thing to do to a child, but fortunately I had a grandmother who sent a brother with me; I am the eldest of five siblings, and my next brother came away to school with me. It was an experience which set me up for life. I am lucky enough to have gone to an excellent public school, with an old boy here, well known to the House—my noble friend Lord Naseby—and Lord Paddy Ashdown, whom many people here will remember. It was a good school. It opened my eyes and gave me opportunities that I would not otherwise have had.

I do not want to penalise people who are not necessarily rich. It has been pointed out time and again, and it is true, that people who look for independent education for their children just want what is best for them. Not everybody is able to do it, but we should not deny it to those people who can afford to do it. This is a misguided policy, and it is clear that the arguments presented about its immediate introduction present a lot of problems for the Government.