Scotland Bill

Debate between Lord Maxton and Lord Bishop of Chester

Tuesday 8th December 2015 Lords Chamber

[The Lord Bishop of Chester]

If the people of Scotland are told, “We toyed with the thought of saying that it was a permanent Parliament but we decided that it wasn’t”, it will simply give the wrong message. Of course I agree that laws can be changed, just as if you have a written constitution it can be changed by some process. However, it corresponds with the reality on the ground.

[Lord Maxton (Lab)]

The fact is that we have a written constitution; we do not have a codified constitution.

[The Lord Bishop of Chester]

I am not sure that I entirely agree with the point, but I will not argue as it would take me down the highways and byways in a way that would not be helpful. I will end on the following point—and I speak as someone who loves Scotland and who will live there in retirement and no doubt will be buried there. When we talk about Scotland, often a slightly grudging spirit comes into our discussions, which is a great mistake. At the end of the day, this provision is a valuable one.