Parliamentary Voting System and Constituencies Bill

Debate between Lord Davies of Stamford and Lord Reid of Cardowan

Tuesday 18th January 2011 Lords Chamber

[Lord Davies of Stamford]

The noble Earl should know that, although I have changed parties, I have kept very much the same political principles all my life. I intend to continue to do so. The noble Earl was possibly not here when the noble Lord, Lord McNally, made the remarks that I have just referred to. I assure him that the noble Lord, Lord McNally, made those remarks; I have not just invented that. It seemed necessary to respond to the remarks and I was taking the obvious opportunity to do so.

[Lord Reid of Cardowan]

The illustration that my noble friend has given is absolutely apposite. What was being discussed throughout that period—proposed, ironically, by a Liberal Prime Minister—was the most important constitutional change of the 19th century. When it was rejected by this House, it led to another 100 years of war in Ireland. The consequences of getting constitutional change wrong are immense. No one is suggesting that this will lead to 100 years of war but it is not an insignificant change. It is, to many people’s minds, the biggest constitutional change in this country since 1832. Therefore, it deserves maximum scrutiny. Least of all does it deserve personal insults.

[Lord Davies of Stamford]

I am extremely grateful to my noble friend for his kind support. I come back to what the noble Earl, Lord Onslow, said.