NHS Pensions

Lord Davies of Brixton Excerpts

Thursday 3rd April 2025 Lords Chamber

[Baroness Merron (Lab)]

I appreciate the point that the noble Baroness refers to. The priority is to get this matter resolved, as she will appreciate. With respect to the NHSBSA, we will also be working closely with it to ensure that the correct service is given in future. Obviously, I want to see this put right to assure people as soon as possible.

[Lord Davies of Brixton (Lab)]

I thank my noble friend for her further clarification of the issues here. This is an extremely complex issue, and I know that better than most because I was involved in the original negotiations, going back to 2011.

What was disappointing about the discussion in the House of Commons on this issue was that there was overemphasis on working out who was to blame rather than on achieving a solution at pace. I thank the Minister here for focusing. Can she give an assurance, first, that everything is being done to resolve this situation? There is also the issue of the way in which the Statement is worded, referring specifically to financial loss. Those people have had to suffer high levels of uncertainty and delay in making their arrangements, which is not easily captured in the term “direct financial losses”. They will be significantly concerned about that lack.

Finally—I feel some sympathy for my noble friend—this is an issue that runs across all the public service schemes. Similar problems are arising in other schemes, not quite to the same extent, but there is failure there. Does my noble friend agree that this illustrates that any changes to public service pensions need to be considered extremely carefully, before we end up with similar problems down the line?

[Baroness Merron (Lab)]

I certainly agree with my noble friend. This runs across all public service pensions. Indeed, it is not just the issue of pensions but the administration and support given. To the point raised by both my noble friend and the noble Baroness, Lady Watkins, I should add that the NHS Business Services Authority and the department are in regular contact with the Pensions Regulator on delivery.

I can certainly give the assurance to my noble friend that we are working cross-government to ensure that these difficulties are corrected as soon as possible. I absolutely recognise the inconvenience, uncertainty and potential distress that have been caused to individuals. As I say, this has a root in it being discriminatory from 2014-15. That said, it falls to us to put that right.