Northern Ireland (Executive Formation) Bill

Debate between Baroness O'Loan and Lord Kerr of Kinlochard

Report stage (Hansard): House of Lords
Wednesday 17th July 2019 Lords Chamber

[Lord Kerr of Kinlochard]

My Lords, that was an extremely impressive speech and I pay tribute to the noble Lord, Lord Shinkwin, but it was surely a speech about Amendment 12, not Amendment 16.

[Baroness O'Loan]

It has been said so often: Amendment 16 is an amendment to Amendment 12.

[Lord Kerr of Kinlochard]

Amendment 16 is entitled:

“Requirement for majority of MLAs to support regulations”.


I confess that I have huge admiration for Amendment 16, because I wish that I had thought of it when we were considering the question of possible prorogation and a crash-out deal with no consultation with Parliament. It is a wonderful thought that we could have written a prescription like this into the law, which would have required the Prime Minister to ring me up and ask, “What’s your view?”, and then work out whether there was a majority in both Houses for and against the crash out.

Actually, it does not make sense. Individually consulting Members of an Assembly that is not meeting does not make sense, I am afraid. It is of course open to the Secretary of State to consult whomever she wants, but to prescribe that she can proceed only if a majority consulted on the telephone or the internet agree is an absurdity.

I also remind those speaking to this amendment that the Minister made it absolutely clear that the consultations would be not about “whether” but about “how”. A number of the speeches that have taken place on Amendment 16 are more appropriate to Amendment 12 because they seem to assume that the consultations will be about “whether” and not about “how”.

Brexit: UK-Irish Relations

Debate between Baroness O'Loan and Lord Kerr of Kinlochard

Tuesday 5th September 2017 Lords Chamber

[Lord Kerr of Kinlochard]

I will bow to the House if it feels I should say no more. I want to make two more points but if the House thinks that I should not make them, I will sit down. Shall I carry on?

[Baroness O'Loan]

Yes.