Financial Services and Markets Bill

Debate between Baroness Chapman of Darlington and Lord Harlech

Report stage
Thursday 8th June 2023 Lords Chamber

[Baroness Chapman of Darlington (Lab)]

Happily, it makes sense to us as well. Without wishing to delay anybody—remembering the exchanges we had before this debate started today—I wonder whether the Minister could indicate the level of fees. He said that consumers would be excluded, which is very important. Are the Government confident that this will not in any way suppress the use of this service? Do they have anything in mind to improve awareness of the service among consumers?

[Lord Harlech (Con)]

My Lords, I am grateful for the contributions in this short debate and thank both noble Baronesses for them.

On case fees, the amendment follows the existing approach under FSMA to allow the FOS to charge fees to respondents. Under this approach, the Government set out through legislation who the FOS is able to charge fees to and it will be for the FOS to set the detail of those case fee rules. This may include when firms should be charged; for example, from the first case or after a certain number of cases. Similarly, the amendment will not prescribe the specific approach the FOS will have to take in charging CMCs—it will be for the FOS to look at those fees. The FOS highlighted concerns from industry about this issue in its feedback statement following its recent consultation on its funding framework, and it acknowledged examples of poor behaviour by CMCs.

The Government agree that there are wider implications and it is critical that the bodies in the financial services regulatory framework, including the FCA and the FOS, co-operate effectively. That is why Clause 38 introduces a statutory duty for the FCA, the FOS and the Financial Services Compensation Scheme to co-operate on issues that have significant implications for each other or for the wider financial services market. Clause 38 also ensures that the FCA, the FOS and the FSCS put appropriate arrangements in place for stakeholders to provide representations on their compliance with this new duty to co-operate on matters with wider implications. These organisations already co-operate on a voluntary basis through the existing wider implications framework. Clause 38 will enhance that co-operation and ensure that these arrangements endure over time while retaining the operational independence of the bodies involved.

As I have set out, the Government are clear that all consumers should be able to access the FOS free of charge, without the need of any CMC support. Amendment 90 will enable this.